Contracts · Updated
NDAs: mutual or one-way, and what a court looks at
A one-way NDA binds only the party that receives information; a mutual NDA binds both, because both will disclose. Neither form is more enforceable: a court reads the contract, starting with how clearly it defines the confidential information, what the recipient may do with it, what is excluded and how long the duty lasts. Federal law sets limits no NDA overrides. An individual is immune from trade secret liability for a confidential report of a suspected violation of law to a government official or a lawyer, and an employer that leaves notice of that immunity out of an employee or contractor agreement loses exemplary damages and attorney fees under the Defend Trade Secrets Act against that person. Pre-dispute nondisclosure clauses are not judicially enforceable in sexual assault or sexual harassment disputes, and no confidentiality agreement, other than one tied to a lawyer's representation of a client, may be used to stop someone from contacting SEC staff about a possible securities law violation.
| Question | One-way (unilateral) NDA | Mutual NDA |
|---|---|---|
| Who is bound | Only the recipient; the disclosing party promises nothing back | Both parties, each as recipient of the other's information |
| Typical uses | A founder showing a plan to an investor or buyer; hiring a contractor, consultant or vendor; employee agreements | Joint ventures and co-development; a sale with diligence on both sides; two companies testing a supply or license deal |
| Main drafting risk | A definition reaching more than the discloser will share, or a mutual form the recipient does not need | Terms that suit one side's information and not the other's; a party that discloses little takes on every duty |
| Immunity notice (18 U.S.C. 1833(b)(3)) | Required when an employer signs it with an employee, contractor or consultant | The same for any individual worker who is a party; in our reading not triggered between two companies |
| Rule | What it says | What it means for an NDA |
|---|---|---|
| Whistleblower immunity, 18 U.S.C. 1833(b)(1) | No criminal or civil liability under any federal or state trade secret law for a disclosure in confidence to a government official or an attorney "solely for the purpose of reporting or investigating a suspected violation of law", or in a court filing made under seal | The confidentiality clause cannot remove that protection |
| Immunity notice, 18 U.S.C. 1833(b)(3)-(4) | Notice of the immunity is required in any agreement with an employee that governs trade secrets or other confidential information; "employee" includes "any individual performing work as a contractor or consultant" | Without it, no exemplary damages or attorney fees under the Act against that person; covers agreements "entered into or updated after" May 11, 2016 |
| Speak Out Act, 42 U.S.C. 19403 | A nondisclosure or nondisparagement clause "agreed to before the dispute arises" is not judicially enforceable in a sexual assault or sexual harassment dispute where the conduct is alleged to have violated federal, tribal or state law | Pre-dispute NDAs cannot silence those claims; trade secrets and proprietary information can still be protected |
| SEC Rule 21F-17, 17 CFR 240.21F-17 | No person may impede anyone from communicating directly with SEC staff about a possible securities law violation, "including enforcing, or threatening to enforce, a confidentiality agreement" | An NDA should not read as a bar on contacting the SEC |
One-way or mutual: follow the information
A one-way NDA puts the duties on the side receiving information; a mutual NDA runs the same promises both ways. Neither label carries its own rules, and a court reads the words, not the title. The choice turns on who will hand over what. When only one side discloses, a mutual form adds duties for a party with nothing to protect; when both disclose, each should check the definitions fit its own information (our reading).
The clauses that decide whether an NDA does its job
In our reading, these are the terms that matter most when an NDA is later relied on:
- A definition of confidential information a stranger could apply: named categories, whether oral disclosures count, and whether anything must be marked.
- Exclusions for information the recipient already had, information that becomes public through no fault of its own, information from someone free to share it, and independent development. These track federal law, under which "reverse engineering, independent derivation, or any other lawful means of acquisition" are not improper means (18 U.S.C. 1839(6)(B)).
- A use restriction (use only for the stated purpose), not only a ban on disclosure.
- Who else may see it: employees and advisors who need it, bound by similar duties.
- A term for new disclosures, a separate survival period, and how trade secrets are treated after it ends.
- Return or destruction at the end, with room for backups and records the law requires to be kept.
- A process for a subpoena or other compelled disclosure: notice and a chance to seek a protective order.
- The federal carve-outs in the table above, plus the immunity notice wherever an individual worker signs.
- No license, no obligation to do the deal, and the governing law and forum.
How an NDA connects to trade secret law
Under the federal Defend Trade Secrets Act, information is a trade secret only if "the owner thereof has taken reasonable measures to keep such information secret" and it "derives independent economic value, actual or potential, from not being generally known" (18 U.S.C. 1839(3)). An NDA is one of the measures an owner can point to, alongside marking, access limits and exit procedures, not in place of them (our reading). The Act gives an owner a federal civil action where the secret relates to a product or service "used in, or intended for use in, interstate or foreign commerce", brought no later than 3 years after the misappropriation was or with reasonable diligence should have been discovered (18 U.S.C. 1836).
The Act does not "preempt or displace" state remedies (18 U.S.C. 1838). The contract and the statutes do different jobs: an NDA can protect information that is confidential without being a trade secret, and trade secret law can protect qualifying information where no NDA was signed (our reading).
The three federal limits in more detail
The immunity notice dates from the Defend Trade Secrets Act (Pub. L. 114-153, May 11, 2016). It can sit in the agreement itself or in a policy document the agreement cross-references (18 U.S.C. 1833(b)(3)). Leaving it out does not void the NDA (our reading); it costs the employer exemplary damages and attorney fees under the Act against an employee who was not given the notice.
The Speak Out Act (Pub. L. 117-224) applies to claims filed on or after December 7, 2022 (42 U.S.C. 19404), so in our reading older NDAs are covered too. It reaches only clauses agreed to before the dispute arose, and "Nothing in this chapter shall prohibit an employer and an employee from protecting trade secrets or proprietary information" (42 U.S.C. 19403).
SEC Rule 21F-17 begins "No person", which in our reading is not limited to public companies, and its only exception concerns information tied to a lawyer's representation of a client. In our reading, one plainly worded carve-out, stating that nothing in the NDA limits reporting to or communicating with a government agency, deals with this rule and the trade secret immunity together.
What a court looks at when an NDA is tested
Most questions a court works through when an NDA is relied on are answered by the document. In our reading they are: whether an agreement was formed and who is bound; whether the information fits the definition and falls outside the exclusions; whether the owner actually treated it as confidential; whether the use or disclosure was within what the NDA allowed, or within a federal carve-out; and what remedy is sought.
The remedy question is where broad clauses run into trouble. The closer a "confidentiality" clause comes to stopping a person from working in a field, the more it looks like a covenant not to compete than an NDA (our reading). Federal trade secret law draws the same line: an injunction under the Act may not "prevent a person from entering into an employment relationship" or "conflict with an applicable State law prohibiting restraints" on a lawful profession, trade or business (18 U.S.C. 1836(b)(3)(A)). An NDA that protects defined information, for a defined purpose, with the carve-outs above, avoids most of that argument.
Common questions
What is the difference between a mutual and a one-way NDA?
A one-way (unilateral) NDA binds only the party receiving information. A mutual NDA binds both, because each will receive the other's information. Otherwise the clauses are the same kind: a definition, exclusions, a use restriction, a term, and return or destruction.
Is a mutual NDA more enforceable than a one-way NDA?
No. The label does not change how a court reads the agreement. What matters is whether the information fits the definition, falls outside the exclusions and was kept confidential, and whether the use or disclosure went beyond what the NDA allowed.
Does an NDA with an employee or contractor need the whistleblower immunity notice?
Yes, if it governs trade secrets or other confidential information and was entered into or updated after May 11, 2016 (18 U.S.C. 1833(b)(3)). Without it, the employer cannot recover exemplary damages or attorney fees under the Defend Trade Secrets Act from that person.
Can an NDA stop someone from reporting sexual harassment?
Not one agreed to before the dispute arose. Under the Speak Out Act, a pre-dispute nondisclosure or nondisparagement clause is not judicially enforceable in a sexual assault or sexual harassment dispute, for claims filed on or after December 7, 2022 (42 U.S.C. 19403-19404).
Does signing an NDA make information a trade secret?
Not by itself. Information is a trade secret only if the owner took reasonable measures to keep it secret and it has independent economic value from not being generally known (18 U.S.C. 1839(3)). An NDA is one of those measures, and it can also protect confidential information that is not a trade secret.
Update log
- November 16, 2026. Published. 18 U.S.C. 1833, 1836, 1838 and 1839 and 42 U.S.C. 19403-19404 (uscode.house.gov, current through Pub. L. 119-124) and SEC Rule 21F-17 (eCFR, as of November 1, 2026), read at the source November 16, 2026.
Sources
- 18 U.S.C. 1833 (whistleblower immunity and notice at (b); current through Pub. L. 119-124)
- 18 U.S.C. 1836 (Defend Trade Secrets Act civil proceedings)
- 18 U.S.C. 1838 (construction with other laws)
- 18 U.S.C. 1839 (definitions: trade secret, improper means)
- 42 U.S.C. 19403 (Speak Out Act, pre-dispute clauses)
- 42 U.S.C. 19404 (Speak Out Act applicability)
- 17 CFR 240.21F-17 (SEC Rule 21F-17; eCFR)
Related
Signing or sending an NDA?
DPS Law drafts and reviews one-way and mutual NDAs, the confidentiality terms in employee and contractor agreements, and the federal notices they need, under North Carolina law. Our attorney is licensed in North Carolina only.