Healthcare business law · Updated

MSOs and friendly PCs: how a management services organization works in North Carolina

A management services organization (MSO) is a company that runs the business side of a medical practice under a written management agreement: the office, billing, technology, marketing and similar non-clinical work. Unlike the practice, it may be owned by people who are not licensed. The "friendly PC" is the licensee-owned practice it serves. In North Carolina the model works only inside three limits. The practice must be owned by Medical Board licensees, or by a combination G.S. 55B-14 permits as the Board describes it; no one other than a licensee may "exercise any authority or influence over the practice of medicine" (21 NCAC 32C .0105(b)); and the Board treats sharing revenue "on a percentage basis with a non-licensee" as fee splitting (NCMB 10.1.1). Where Medicare or Medicaid business is involved, the federal management contracts safe harbor protects the agreement only if it meets all its conditions, among them a signed agreement of at least one year with a fee methodology set in advance at fair market value.

Who does what in a North Carolina MSO structure (as of November 16, 2026)
FunctionThe MSO (may be owned by non-licensees)The licensee-owned practiceWhere the rule comes from
Owning the medical practice entityNo share at all, not even a minority oneOwned entirely by licensees, or by a combination G.S. 55B-14 permits; the Board approves ownership changes in advanceNCMB 10.1.2 (amended Sep. 2025); NCMB practice ownership FAQ: shares "may only be held by a licensee"
Office management, billing services, marketing and advertisingYes, as paid management servicesPays for them and stays responsible for the practice (our reading)NCMB laser guidance, Q6 (undated)
Clinical decisions and treatment protocolsNo authority or influenceYes, and only licensees21 NCAC 32C .0105(b)
The management feePaid for services. Where the unlicensed person is also paid as an employee or contractor performing procedures, the Board's laser guidance bars splitting fees with that person "on a per-procedure or percentage basis for medical services provided"May not "share revenue on a percentage basis with a non-licensee" except as the law permitsNCMB 10.1.1 (amended Sep. 2021); laser guidance, Q6
Where the revenue goesIts fee. A structure with "the bulk of the practice's revenue going to the non-licensee" is the straw-ownership pattern the Board's 2024 Forum article describesCollects for its own services (our reading)NCMB Forum, Aug. 30, 2024
Medicare, Medicaid and other federal program businessAgreement should meet the management contracts safe harbor to be protectedSame agreement, same conditions42 CFR 1001.952(d)
Ways to set the management fee, read against the North Carolina and federal rules
Fee modelNC Medical BoardFederal safe harbor, 42 CFR 1001.952(d)Our reading
Percentage of collections or revenue"a licensee cannot share revenue on a percentage basis with a non-licensee" (10.1.1)The methodology may not take into account "the volume or value of any referrals or business otherwise generated between the parties" that federal programs pay forAvoid for a lay-owned MSO in North Carolina, whatever the payer mix
Per procedure, per patient or per visitThe laser guidance rules out splitting fees with the unlicensed person "on a per-procedure or percentage basis for medical services provided"Same volume-or-value problem where federal business is involvedAvoid
Salary or hourly rate for the people doing the workThe laser guidance's answer for an unlicensed person paid to perform procedures: "salary or hourly wage to avoid improper fee splitting"Fits if the method is set in advance, in a signed writing of at least a year, at fair market valueFits both, but awkward for a full-service MSO
Fixed fee for a defined list of services, set in advance at fair market valueNot a percentage of revenue; the Board's statements do not address it by nameFits the same conditionsThe usual approach. Document the fair-market-value basis before the first invoice, and reset it by written amendment, not by formula tied to collections
The federal management contracts safe harbor and the Stark personal services exception, side by side (eCFR, read November 16, 2026)
ConditionAnti-Kickback safe harbor, 42 CFR 1001.952(d)(1)Stark exception, 42 CFR 411.357(d)(1)
Writing"set out in writing and signed by the parties""set out in writing, is signed by the parties, and specifies the services covered"
Services coveredCovers all the agent's services for the term and specifies themCovers all the physician's services to the entity; a cross-referenced master list of contracts counts
Term"not less than 1 year""at least 1 year"
PayMethodology "set in advance", consistent with fair market value, not based on the volume or value of federal program referrals or businessCompensation "set in advance", not above fair market value, not based on the volume or value of referrals or other business
Amount of servicesNot more than "reasonably necessary" for a commercially reasonable business purposeNot more than "reasonable and necessary for the legitimate business purposes"
Lawful purposeNo counseling or promotion of an activity that violates state or federal lawThe same

What an MSO is, and what a friendly PC is

An MSO structure is "two entities and one agreement", as our telehealth and MSO page puts it. The first entity is the medical practice: a professional corporation (PC) or professional limited liability company (PLLC) owned by licensees and registered with the North Carolina Medical Board before its articles are filed with the Secretary of State. The second is the management services organization, an ordinary company that a lay investor may own. The agreement between them, the management services agreement, does most of the work: the scope of services, the term, termination rights, who owns the records, and how the management fee is calculated.

"Friendly PC" is industry shorthand, not a legal term. None of the North Carolina rules or Medical Board statements we read for this page uses it, and none mentions MSOs or management services organizations by name. It describes a practice owned by a licensee who works with the people behind the MSO and is often chosen by them. Investors regularly arrive assuming an MSO lets them own a medical practice. It does not. What it lets them own is a company that contracts with the practice for the non-clinical side of the business, on terms that leave the practice in charge of the medicine. When the practice is friendly in name only and the MSO makes the decisions, the Medical Board's word for the licensee is "straw owner".

The North Carolina rule the structure has to meet

The Medical Board's position statement on the corporate practice of medicine (adopted March 2016, amended September 2025) says the owners of a business engaged in the practice of medicine must be licensees of the Board or "one of the combinations permitted in N.C. Gen. Stat. § 55B-14" (NCMB 10.1.2). Its exceptions are hospitals, health maintenance organizations, public health clinics, charitable nonprofits and practices owned by nonprofit hospitals. The Board's ownership FAQ is direct about investors: "Shares of capital stock or membership may only be held by a licensee, as defined in NC General Statute 55B-2(2)", and a change in ownership of a professional corporation needs the Board's "prior approval" (NCMB FAQ). The Board's February 2026 Forum puts it in one line: "State law requires that medical practices be owned by medical professionals licensed by NCMB" (NCMB Forum, Feb. 26, 2026). So a lay investor cannot hold even a minority interest in the practice. The investor's return comes through the MSO's contract, which is why the contract is where the scrutiny falls.

Ownership is only half of the rule. The Board's own rules for professional corporations say: "No person other than a licensee of the Board shall exercise any authority or influence over the practice of medicine as defined in Article 1 of Chapter 90" (21 NCAC 32C .0105(b), last amended effective May 1, 2012). A structure in which a licensee holds every share while the MSO decides how patients are treated fails that test, whatever the share register says. The position statement also closes the obvious workaround: whether a licensee is an employee or an independent contractor "is not determinative" of whether the licensee is aiding and abetting the corporate practice of medicine (10.1.2).

What the MSO can do

The Medical Board's clearest description of a management arrangement is in its guidance on laser hair and tattoo removal, an undated question-and-answer document. Asked how a lay owner can restructure, it says that "the unlicensed person enters into a Management Services Contract with a licensed practitioner who has purchased the medical laser (or the entire practice)", and that "The licensed practitioner is permitted to compensate the unlicensed person for management services in the form of managing the office, performing billing services, marketing and advertising the practice or other activities that do not constitute the practice of medicine" (NCMB laser guidance, Q6). The document was written about lasers, but the model it describes is the MSO model.

Our telehealth and MSO page lists what an MSO contracts for: billing, staffing, premises, technology and marketing, on arm's-length terms. In our reading, each of those has a line that the agreement should draw expressly. The MSO can employ and lease front-office and administrative staff and run payroll and HR administration; who is engaged to provide care, and how that care is supervised, is the practice's decision. The MSO can supply the electronic health record system; the records belong to the practice, and the agreement should say so. The MSO can run marketing; the advertising is the practice's advertising, and the practice signs off on what it says. The MSO can negotiate a lease or buy equipment for the practice to use; which clinical equipment the practice uses is a clinical choice.

North Carolina has not published a list of the decisions an MSO may not make, but California's Medical Board has, and it is a useful map of where management turns into control. Its guidance says that "businesses that control medical records, the hiring and firing of healthcare staff, decisions over coding and billing, and the approving or selection of medical equipment or drugs, violate the law", and that "Businesses that provide management services, franchises or other models that result in any unlicensed person or entity influencing or making medical decisions are in violation of the law" (Medical Board of California, undated). In our reading, California is stricter than North Carolina's published statements on some of these points, coding and billing among them. We use its list as a checklist, not as North Carolina law.

The management fee

In our reading, the fee is where a North Carolina MSO structure most often goes wrong. The Board's statement on referral fees and fee splitting (adopted November 1993, amended September 2021) says that, except where the law permits it, "a licensee cannot share revenue on a percentage basis with a non-licensee", and "To do so is fee splitting and is grounds for disciplinary action" (NCMB 10.1.1). The exception it cites is G.S. 55B-14(c), which the Board's other statements describe as the provision for combinations of licensees; in our reading it does not cover a lay-owned management company. The laser guidance, in the same answer that allows a management services contract, says a licensed practitioner "would not be permitted to split fees with the unlicensed person on a per-procedure or percentage basis for medical services provided"; where the unlicensed person is paid as an employee or contractor performing procedures, the practitioner would pay "based on a salary or hourly wage to avoid improper fee splitting" (Q6).

That rules out a percentage of the practice's collections as the fee for a lay-owned MSO. A fee that moves with clinical revenue can read as a share of the practice rather than payment for administration. The usual alternative is a fee set at fair market value for defined services, documented before it is charged: a fixed monthly amount for a written list of services, with the basis for the number (a valuation, a cost build-up or market comparisons) kept on file, and any change made by written amendment. In our reading, a fixed fee is a reasonable extension of the Board's "salary or hourly wage" answer, because it does not rise or fall with what the practice bills; the Board has not addressed fixed fees by name. Watch for terms that bring the percentage back in through a side door: a year-end true-up to a share of collections, a "performance" bonus measured by revenue, or a fee defined as whatever is left after the physician's salary.

An MSO that wants upside has other routes that do not depend on the practice's revenue: the value of the MSO itself, which it may sell, and fees for services the MSO provides to more than one practice. Each has its own questions, but none of them is fee splitting on its face.

The federal layer: the Anti-Kickback Statute

If the practice bills Medicare, Medicaid or another federal health care program, the management agreement also has to be read against the federal Anti-Kickback Statute. It makes it a felony for anyone who "knowingly and willfully solicits or receives any remuneration" in return for referring a patient for, or for ordering or arranging, items or services "for which payment may be made in whole or in part under a Federal health care program", and for anyone who "knowingly and willfully offers or pays" it. The penalty is a fine of up to $100,000, up to 10 years in prison, or both; and "a person need not have actual knowledge of this section or specific intent to commit a violation of this section" (42 U.S.C. 1320a-7b, current through Pub. L. 119-124). Our Anti-Kickback page covers the statute in full.

The Office of Inspector General's safe harbor for personal services and management contracts protects a payment from a principal to an agent "as long as all of the following standards are met" (42 CFR 1001.952(d)(1)):

  • "The agency agreement is set out in writing and signed by the parties."
  • It "covers all of the services the agent provides to the principal for the term of the agreement and specifies the services to be provided by the agent."
  • "The term of the agreement is not less than 1 year."
  • "The methodology for determining the compensation paid to the agent over the term of the agreement is set in advance, is consistent with fair market value in arm's-length transactions, and is not determined in a manner that takes into account the volume or value of any referrals or business otherwise generated between the parties for which payment may be made in whole or in part under Medicare, Medicaid, or other Federal health care programs."
  • The services "do not involve the counseling or promotion of a business arrangement or other activity that violates any State or Federal law."
  • "The aggregate services contracted for do not exceed those which are reasonably necessary to accomplish the commercially reasonable business purpose of the services."

How the safe harbor changed, and what missing it means

The current text dates from OIG's final rule of December 2, 2020 (85 FR 77684), effective January 19, 2021, which finalized "changes to increase flexibility for part-time or sporadic arrangements and arrangements for which aggregate compensation is not known in advance" (85 FR 77684). In our reading, the practical result is in the text above: the methodology for the fee, not the total dollar amount, has to be fixed in advance. A fixed monthly fee or an hourly rate for defined services meets that, and OIG said an arrangement can fit the safe harbor using "an hourly rate or other set, verifiable formula" (85 FR 77684, at 77839), so a percentage of collections fixed in the agreement is not excluded by that condition alone. Its problem is the separate condition that the methodology not take into account "the volume or value of any referrals or business otherwise generated between the parties", because a share of collections rises with any such business.

Safe harbors are optional. The same rule says: "Compliance with a safe harbor is voluntary" and "Arrangements are not necessarily unlawful because they do not fit in a safe harbor." In our reading, an agreement outside it is judged on its own facts, including intent, and a lay-owned MSO in North Carolina should meet the safe harbor's conditions anyway, because the state's fee-splitting position pushes the fee toward the same structure: set in advance, at fair market value, not tied to revenue.

If a physician owner refers patients to the MSO or one of its affiliates for services the Stark law covers, Stark's personal service arrangements exception comes into play as well, and its terms are close to the safe harbor's (third table above; 42 CFR 411.357(d)). Our Stark law page explains when Stark applies.

When a friendly PC becomes a straw owner

The Medical Board has described the patterns it is looking for. In a 2024 article in its Lessons from the Disciplinary Committee series, it describes straw ownership as an arrangement in which "a licensed physician is made the sole shareholder of a practice controlled and operated by an individual who is not licensed by NCMB", and says that "In many instances, the physician straw owner signs a management agreement that results in the bulk of the practice's revenue going to the non-licensee". It also describes arrangements in which a licensee works in the practice but "treatment protocols are dictated by the non-licensed owners", and calls that, like a hands-off medical director role, "inappropriate and unlawful in North Carolina". A licensee hired as medical director of a practice owned by a non-licensed individual "may be aiding and abetting the unlicensed practice of medicine in North Carolina, which could result in regulatory action" (NCMB Forum, Aug. 30, 2024). In 2026 it added that it "investigates situations where licensees get involved in helping to run medical practices owned by non-physicians" (NCMB Forum, Feb. 26, 2026).

In our reading, these are the management agreement terms that most often turn a friendly PC into a straw owner, and the ones we redraft first:

  • The MSO writes, approves or can veto clinical protocols, formularies or treatment pathways.
  • The MSO can hire, fire, schedule or set the pay of clinicians without the practice's approval.
  • The patient records sit with the MSO, or pass to it when the agreement ends.
  • The practice's operating accounts are controlled by the MSO, with no practice signatory, and receivables are swept before the practice's own obligations are met.
  • The fee takes most of the revenue whatever services are actually provided, or is reset by formula against collections.
  • The physician owner is paid a flat stipend to hold the shares while the MSO runs everything else.
  • The physician cannot sell, close or change the practice without the MSO's consent, beyond what is reasonable to protect the MSO's contract.

Succession: when the friendly physician leaves

Every friendly-PC structure has to answer one practical question: what happens when the physician owner resigns, dies, loses a license, or falls out with the business. Shares may be held only by licensees, and the Board approves a change in ownership in advance (NCMB FAQ), so the shares cannot simply pass to the MSO or its investors. Succession is handled by transfer restrictions agreed in advance, usually a stock transfer or succession agreement among the practice, its owner and the MSO.

In our reading, the way that agreement is written matters as much as having one. An agreement that lets the MSO name the next owner at will, for a nominal price, at any time, is the kind of term that makes the current owner look like a stand-in. One that limits transfers to a qualified North Carolina licensee, conditions them on the Board's approval, sets the price by a formula agreed at the start, and is triggered by defined events (death, disability, loss of license, breach) is easier to defend and still protects the MSO's investment.

What a wrong structure costs

The licensee carries the most immediate risk. Licensees who provide services for a business engaged in the corporate practice of medicine "may be subject to disciplinary action by the Board", and a licensee who shares revenue on a percentage basis with a non-licensee risks discipline for fee splitting (10.1.1). The lay owner is exposed as well: "the Board may seek injunctive relief against lay owners" (10.1.2). The Board describes the unlicensed practice of medicine as "a crime in North Carolina pursuant to N.C. Gen. Stat. § 90-18(a)" (laser guidance, Q7), and aiding and abetting it as "a misdemeanor crime" (Forum, Feb. 26, 2026).

Where federal program business is involved, the Anti-Kickback Statute's criminal penalties add to that. Beyond the penalties, a structure that fails usually has to be unwound, and unwinding a live practice is the expensive version of getting it right at the start.

Cash-pay practices

A practice that never bills Medicare, Medicaid or another federal program, and never causes a claim to one, is in our reading largely outside the Anti-Kickback Statute and the Stark law. It is not outside North Carolina's rules. The Board's fee-splitting and corporate practice statements are not limited to any payer: the bar on sharing revenue "on a percentage basis with a non-licensee" applies to a cash-pay med spa or telehealth practice exactly as it does to a practice that bills insurance. A cash-pay practice is not automatically outside any of it. The Board also notes that "referral fees are prohibited by state law pursuant to N.C. Gen. Stat. § 90-401" (10.1.1), and our telehealth and MSO page summarizes North Carolina's own self-referral statute.

Other states

DPS Law's attorney is licensed in North Carolina only, and an MSO that serves practices in other states needs each state's answer. The rules differ widely. California's Medical Board says "Laypersons or lay entities may not own any part of a medical practice" (citing Business and Professions Code section 2400), and that MSOs "arranging for advertising, or providing medical services rather than only providing administrative staff and services for a physician's medical practice" are "also engaging in illegal conduct" (Medical Board of California). Washington's Attorney General has described the rule there as "a business entity may not employ medical professionals to practice their licensed professions" absent legislative authorization (AGO 2020 No. 5). South Carolina's S. 46, introduced January 14, 2025, would declare "contract provisions which interfere with a physician-patient relationship or allow for the corporate practice of medicine" against public policy; the legislature's site shows it still in the Senate Committee on Labor, Commerce and Industry (S. 46).

We have not summarized any state statute we could not read at the official source on the date of this update. Our state-by-state page on the corporate practice of medicine lists the states we have checked and the date we checked them.

Setting up an MSO structure in North Carolina: the order of work

In our experience the sequence matters, because the practice entity has to exist, and be registered, before the agreements can bind it.

  • Form and register the practice: certificate of registration from the Medical Board first, then the articles with the Secretary of State (steps and fees in who can own a med spa in North Carolina).
  • Form the MSO as an ordinary company, with its own owners, bank accounts and books.
  • Write the list of services the MSO will provide, and record the fair-market-value basis for the fee before the first invoice.
  • Draft the management services agreement: a term of at least one year, signed; the services; the fee methodology; clinical decisions reserved to the practice; records owned by the practice; the practice's control of its own accounts; termination rights on both sides.
  • Draft the succession terms: transfers only to qualified licensees, on Board approval, at a price set by formula, on defined events.
  • Put the practice's sign-off on advertising and clinical hiring into the agreement, not just into practice.
  • Review the structure every year, and before the practice adds a state, a service line or an outside investor.

Common questions

What is a management services organization in healthcare?

A company that provides the non-clinical side of a medical practice, such as office management, billing, staff administration, technology and marketing, under a written management services agreement. Unlike the practice, it may be owned by people who are not licensed. It may not make or influence medical decisions.

Can a non-physician own a medical practice in North Carolina through an MSO?

Not the practice. The Medical Board says shares in a medical professional corporation or PLLC "may only be held by a licensee". A non-licensee can own the MSO, which contracts with the licensee-owned practice for non-clinical services and is paid a fee for them.

What is a friendly PC?

Industry shorthand for a licensee-owned practice that works with an MSO and is often chosen by its owners. It is lawful in North Carolina only if the licensee really controls the medicine and the fee is not a share of revenue. If the MSO makes the decisions, the Board treats the licensee as a straw owner.

Can an MSO charge a percentage of collections in North Carolina?

Not if the MSO is owned by non-licensees. The Medical Board's position is that a licensee "cannot share revenue on a percentage basis with a non-licensee", which it treats as fee splitting and grounds for discipline. The usual alternative is a fixed fee for defined services, set in advance at fair market value.

Does the Anti-Kickback Statute apply to a management agreement?

Where the practice bills Medicare, Medicaid or another federal program, yes. The management contracts safe harbor (42 CFR 1001.952(d)) protects an agreement only if it meets every condition, including that it is in writing and signed, lasts at least a year, covers and specifies all the services, and pays by a methodology set in advance at fair market value that does not take into account the volume or value of referrals or business otherwise generated between the parties for which federal programs may pay.

Is a cash-pay practice outside these rules?

Outside most of the federal rules, in our reading, but not outside North Carolina's. The Medical Board's corporate practice and fee-splitting positions apply whatever the payer.

Do other states treat MSOs the same way?

No. In our reading, California is stricter than North Carolina on what an MSO may control, and South Carolina has a bill pending on the corporate practice of medicine. Each state needs its own answer, from a lawyer licensed there.

Update log

  • November 17, 2026. Corrected: (1) "How the safe harbor changed" said a percentage of collections fails the set-in-advance condition. Since January 19, 2021, 42 CFR 1001.952(d)(1)(iv) requires the fee methodology to be set in advance, and OIG said "an hourly rate or other set, verifiable formula" can qualify (85 FR 77684, at 77839), so the page now places a percentage fee's problem in the separate volume-or-value condition. (2) First table, "The management fee": the laser guidance's bar on splitting fees "on a per-procedure or percentage basis for medical services provided" is about paying the unlicensed person as an employee or contractor performing procedures (NCMB laser guidance, Q6), and the row now says so. (3) FAQ on the Anti-Kickback Statute: the condition covers the volume or value of referrals or business "otherwise generated between the parties" for which federal programs may pay (42 CFR 1001.952(d)(1)(iv), eCFR), not all federal program business. Each source re-read November 17, 2026.
  • November 16, 2026. Published. The Medical Board's position statements 10.1.1 and 10.1.2, practice ownership FAQ, professional corporation and PLLC registration pages, laser guidance and two Forum articles, 21 NCAC 32C .0105 (Cornell LII copy), 42 CFR 1001.952 and 411.357 (eCFR), OIG's 2020 final rule, 42 U.S.C. 1320a-7b (current through Pub. L. 119-124), the Medical Board of California's guidance, Washington AGO 2020 No. 5 and South Carolina S. 46, all read at the source November 16, 2026. North Carolina's statutes are described as the Medical Board describes them.

Sources

Related

Published November 16, 2026; updated November 17, 2026. General information, not legal advice. See the disclaimer.

Setting up or reviewing an MSO structure?

DPS Law forms the practice entity and the MSO, drafts the management services agreement and the succession terms, and reviews existing structures under North Carolina law and the federal safe harbor. Our attorney is licensed in North Carolina only; for a practice in another state, talk to a lawyer licensed there.

Telehealth and MSO structures