Telehealth and MSOs · Updated

MSO management fee calculator: flat fee, cost-plus or a percentage

In our reading, how a management services organization is paid is where many MSO structures run into trouble. Enter the practice's numbers to see what each fee structure pays the MSO as the practice grows or shrinks, and what the federal and North Carolina rules say about the structure you pick.

MSO management fee calculator

The practice
The fee structures to compare
About the arrangement

What the rules say about this structure

  • The Anti-Kickback Statute reaches federal program business

    The federal Anti-Kickback Statute makes it a felony to knowingly and willfully offer, pay, solicit or receive any remuneration to induce, or in return for, referrals or the arranging for or recommending of items or services for which payment may be made in whole or in part under a federal health care program. The criminal maximum is a $100,000 fine and 10 years in prison, and OIG may also impose a civil penalty of up to $127,973 per act, the 2025 level that HHS kept for 2026. A management fee is protected by the personal services and management contracts safe harbor only if it meets every condition, but OIG says failing one "does not render an arrangement automatically illegal"; the arrangement is then reviewed on "the totality of the facts and circumstances, including the intent of the parties."[1][2][3][4][5][7]

  • Signed writing, every service listed, one-year term

    The safe harbor requires the agreement to be "set out in writing and signed by the parties", to cover and specify all of the services the MSO provides to the practice for the term, and to run for "not less than 1 year." OIG has said the writing can be one signed agreement or a signed collection of documents that together contain every required element. Its compliance guidance also asks whether the parties document the services they provide and whether arrangements "are actually conducted according to the terms of the written agreements."[5][6][7]

  • Fair market value and commercial reasonableness

    The fee methodology must be "consistent with fair market value in arm's-length transactions", and the services contracted for may not exceed those "reasonably necessary to accomplish the commercially reasonable business purpose of the services." OIG has declined to define either term for the Anti-Kickback Statute and is barred by statute from opining on fair market value in an advisory opinion, so the figures in this estimator are not a fair market value finding. OIG's compliance guidance asks, "Is the determination of fair market value based upon a reasonable methodology that is uniformly applied and properly documented?", and in Advisory Opinion 25-03 the requestors certified each fee as consistent with fair market value "as established by a reputable, independent third-party valuator."[5][6][7][11]

  • A fixed fee is set in advance

    A fixed fee for a written list of services is a compensation methodology set in advance, and because it does not change with the number of patients or the practice's collections, it does not move with referrals or business generated between the parties. In Advisory Opinion 25-03, OIG concluded that fees a practice would pay to a management services organization and the telehealth practice it manages would not generate prohibited remuneration, where the requestors certified that the fee methodology would be set in advance and consistent with fair market value, noting that paying the hourly fee "regardless of whether" the practice was reimbursed "decreases the likelihood" that the fee takes into account the volume or value of referrals or business generated between the parties. An advisory opinion protects only the parties that requested it, and a fixed fee still has to be consistent with fair market value for the services actually provided.[5][11]

  • Percentage fee and the volume-or-value condition

    Since January 19, 2021, the safe harbor requires the compensation methodology, rather than the total amount, to be set in advance, so, in our reading, a percentage fixed in the signed agreement is not ruled out on that ground alone. The harder condition is that the methodology may not take into account "the volume or value of any referrals or business otherwise generated between the parties" that federal programs pay for, and a fee measured by collections rises with that business whenever the MSO or its owners help generate it. In 1998 OIG said percentage compensation for marketing services "may implicate" the statute and stated a "longstanding concern that percentage billing arrangements may increase the risk of upcoding and similar abusive billing practices." Missing the safe harbor is not itself a violation; the arrangement is then judged on its facts, including intent.[5][6][8][9][7]

  • Cost-plus: costs and markup fixed before payment

    OIG said in its 2020 rule that an arrangement can fit the safe harbor "by using an hourly rate or other set, verifiable formula", but that whether an employee lease paid on "actual expenses incurred" meets the set-in-advance condition "would depend on the facts and circumstances." Parties must determine "whether the compensation methodology over the term of the agreement is set in advance before any payment under the arrangement is made", which in our reading means the cost categories, the markup and the way costs are verified belong in the signed agreement. OIG's example was that a bonus taking into account referrals between the parties, passed through as a cost, would leave the compensation unprotected, and the markup is part of the compensation that must be consistent with fair market value.[6][5]

  • Paying the MSO to bring in patients

    The Anti-Kickback Statute reaches payment for "arranging for or recommending" federally payable items or services, not only for direct referrals, and OIG said in 1998 that percentage compensation for marketing services "may implicate" the statute. In 2022 OIG described a per-patient-encounter fee as a "per-click" fee structure, which "generally is inherently reflective of the volume or value of referrals or business otherwise generated between the parties." Measured against the safe harbor, a marketing fee fixed in advance for defined advertising work does not vary with the patients generated; a percentage or per-patient fee does.[1][8][10][5]

  • Fees between parties who refer to each other

    When the MSO's owners or affiliates and the practice refer patients to each other, the management fee runs between parties who can generate federal program business for each other. OIG's compliance guidance asks, "Is the entity paying an inflated rate to a potential referral source?" and whether a party is "receiving free or below-market-rate items or services", so the fee can be questioned whether it sits above or below fair market value. The safe harbor also excludes a methodology that takes into account "the volume or value of any referrals or business otherwise generated between the parties"; a percentage of collections rises with the patients the owners send, while a fixed fee does not.[7][5]

  • Stark: physician owners and designated health services

    Stark bars a physician who has a financial relationship with an entity, an ownership interest or a compensation arrangement, directly or through an immediate family member, from referring Medicare patients to it for designated health services such as clinical laboratory, radiology and imaging, physical therapy and outpatient prescription drugs, and bars the entity from billing for them, unless an exception applies. The entity is the one that performs or bills those services, usually the practice or an affiliate rather than a management-only MSO, and an ownership interest can run through an entity that owns the provider. Each element of an exception must be met; the personal service arrangements exception, for example, requires a signed writing specifying the services, a term of at least 1 year, and compensation "set in advance" that "does not exceed fair market value" and is not determined in any manner that takes into account "the volume or value of referrals or other business generated between the parties."[12][13][14]

  • NC Medical Board: percentage revenue sharing is fee splitting

    The North Carolina Medical Board's position statement 10.1.1 (amended September 2021) says that, except where G.S. 55B-14(c) permits it, "a licensee cannot share revenue on a percentage basis with a non-licensee", and "To do so is fee splitting and is grounds for disciplinary action." G.S. 55B-14(c) lists combinations of licensed professionals who may form a professional corporation together; a management company owned by people who are not Board licensees is not among them. The statement is not limited to any payer, so it applies to cash-pay practices too, and a fee set as a percentage of the practice's collections and paid to such an MSO matches the arrangement it describes.[15][20]

  • NC: fixed and cost-based fees, and the revenue share

    The Medical Board's fee-splitting statement addresses revenue shared "on a percentage basis" and does not address fixed or cost-based fees by name. The Board's laser guidance says a licensee "is permitted to compensate the unlicensed person for management services in the form of managing the office, performing billing services, marketing and advertising the practice or other activities that do not constitute the practice of medicine." The Board has also described straw ownership, in which "the physician straw owner signs a management agreement that results in the bulk of the practice's revenue going to the non-licensee", so compare the modeled fee with the practice's revenue at each level, whatever structure produces it.[15][18][19]

  • NC: licensees own the practice and direct care

    The Medical Board's position statement 10.1.2 (amended September 2025) says businesses practicing medicine in North Carolina "must be owned in their entirety by persons holding active North Carolina licenses", or by a combination G.S. 55B-14 permits, so investors who are not licensees can take part through a management company but cannot own any part of the practice. The Board's rule for professional corporations adds: "No person other than a licensee of the Board shall exercise any authority or influence over the practice of medicine as defined in Article 1 of Chapter 90." The Board has called arrangements in which "treatment protocols are dictated by the non-licensed owners" "inappropriate and unlawful in North Carolina."[16][17][18][19]

  • NC: no payment for securing patients

    G.S. 90-401 says a licensed health care provider "shall not financially compensate in any manner a person, firm, or corporation for recommending or securing the health care provider's employment by a patient", but it does not prohibit "a health care provider's purchase of advertising which does not entail direct personal contact or telephone contact of a potential patient." A violation is grounds for discipline by the provider's licensing board (G.S. 90-402), and the Medical Board's statement 10.1.1, which is not limited to any payer, says referral fees are prohibited by state law and, for voucher advertising, asks that the fee represent "reasonable compensation for the cost of advertising." In our reading, a marketing fee paid per patient secured is the kind of payment the statute bars, while a fee for advertising without direct personal or telephone contact is the kind of purchase it allows.[21][15]

  • NC self-referral law: entities the referring licensees invest in

    G.S. 90-406 bars a licensed health care provider from referring a patient "to any entity in which the health care provider or group practice or any member of the group practice is an investor", and an investor includes anyone holding equity, debt or certain real property interests, directly or indirectly. It applies to "designated health care services", defined as services covered by a Chapter 58 health benefit plan, an ERISA plan, a federal or State employee insurance program, Medicare or Medicaid, so commercially insured patients count, not only federal ones. It reaches an MSO or affiliate only if that business "provides health care services"; a violation is grounds for discipline and carries civil penalties of up to $20,000 per bill or claim and $75,000 per circumvention arrangement.[22]

General information for modeling management fee structures, not legal advice; whether a fee is consistent with fair market value is a question for a documented valuation of the services, not a calculator.

Sources for these notes

  1. 42 U.S.C. 1320a-7b(b), the Anti-Kickback Statute (uscode.house.gov, current through Pub. L. 119-124) (as of November 17, 2026)
  2. 42 U.S.C. 1320a-7a(a)(7), civil money penalty for kickbacks (uscode.house.gov, current through Pub. L. 119-124) (as of November 17, 2026)
  3. 45 CFR 102.3, inflation-adjusted civil money penalties (eCFR, up to date as of Nov. 13, 2026) (as of November 17, 2026)
  4. HHS, No Adjustment to HHS Civil Monetary Penalty Amounts for 2026, 91 FR 66566 (Oct. 21, 2026) (as of November 17, 2026)
  5. 42 CFR 1001.952(d), personal services and management contracts safe harbor (eCFR, up to date as of Nov. 13, 2026) (as of November 17, 2026)
  6. OIG final rule amending the safe harbors, 85 FR 77684 (Dec. 2, 2020; effective Jan. 19, 2021) (as of November 17, 2026)
  7. HHS-OIG, General Compliance Program Guidance (Nov. 6, 2023) (as of November 17, 2026)
  8. HHS-OIG Advisory Opinion No. 98-4 (Apr. 15, 1998): management company paid costs plus a percentage of practice revenue (as of November 17, 2026)
  9. HHS-OIG, Compliance Program Guidance for Third-Party Medical Billing Companies, 63 FR 70138 (Dec. 18, 1998; listed in OIG's CPG archive) (as of November 17, 2026)
  10. HHS-OIG Advisory Opinion No. 22-09 (Apr. 25, 2022): per-patient-encounter fees (as of November 17, 2026)
  11. HHS-OIG Advisory Opinion No. 25-03 (June 6, 2025): fees to telehealth management services organizations (as of November 17, 2026)
  12. 42 U.S.C. 1395nn, physician self-referral (Stark) law (uscode.house.gov, current through Pub. L. 119-124) (as of November 17, 2026)
  13. 42 CFR 411.351, Stark definitions, including entity (eCFR, up to date as of Nov. 13, 2026) (as of November 17, 2026)
  14. 42 CFR 411.357(d), Stark personal service arrangements exception (eCFR, up to date as of Nov. 13, 2026) (as of November 17, 2026)
  15. NC Medical Board position statement 10.1.1, Referral Fees and Fee Splitting (adopted Nov. 1993, amended Sept. 2021) (as of November 17, 2026)
  16. NC Medical Board position statement 10.1.2, Corporate Practice of Medicine (adopted Mar. 2016, amended Sept. 2025) (as of November 17, 2026)
  17. 21 NCAC 32C .0105, Medical Board rule on professional corporations (Cornell LII copy; amended eff. May 1, 2012) (as of November 17, 2026)
  18. NC Medical Board, laser hair and tattoo removal guidance, Q6 (undated; PDF created July 2017) (as of November 17, 2026)
  19. NC Medical Board Forum, Are you aiding the unlicensed practice of medicine? (Aug. 30, 2024) (as of November 17, 2026)
  20. G.S. 55B-14, types of professional services (read from the Internet Archive's June 29, 2025 capture of ncleg.gov, which blocks automated reads) (as of November 17, 2026)
  21. G.S. 90-400 to 90-402, referral fees and payment for certain solicitations prohibited (read from the Internet Archive's Feb. 11, 2026 capture of ncleg.gov) (as of November 17, 2026)
  22. G.S. 90-405 to 90-408, self-referrals by health care providers (read from the Internet Archive's Mar. 6, 2026 capture of ncleg.gov) (as of November 17, 2026)

How the numbers work

  • Flat fee: the same amount each month, whatever the practice collects.
  • Cost plus: the MSO's costs of serving the practice, plus a markup.
  • Percentage of collections: a share of what the practice collects, so the fee rises and falls with its business.
  • The three revenue columns hold the MSO's costs fixed, to show how much each fee moves with the practice's business alone.

Why the structure matters

The federal safe harbor for management contracts asks that the method of setting the fee be fixed in advance, consistent with fair market value, and not set in a way that takes into account the volume or value of referrals or business otherwise generated between the parties for which federal health care programs may pay. A fee that rises with the practice's collections is the hardest of the three to square with that last condition when the MSO's side can generate that business. Missing a safe harbor is not itself a violation; the arrangement is then judged on its facts.

North Carolina adds its own line. The Medical Board's position statement 10.1.1 says that, except where G.S. 55B-14(c) permits it, a licensee cannot share revenue on a percentage basis with a non-licensee, and calls that fee splitting. The notes beside the calculator change with the structure and the answers you pick, and each links its source.

What it cannot tell you

  • Fair market value. That is a question for a documented valuation of the services, not a calculator.
  • Whether the MSO's role crosses into control of clinical decisions, which turns on the management agreement as a whole, not only the fee.
  • Rules in states other than North Carolina. The practice ownership checker covers ownership state by state.

Common questions

Can an MSO charge a percentage of collections?

Under federal law, falling outside the safe harbor is not itself a violation; the arrangement is judged on its facts, including what the parties intended. In North Carolina the answer is narrower: the Medical Board's position statement 10.1.1 says a licensee cannot share revenue on a percentage basis with a non-licensee, except where G.S. 55B-14(c) permits it, and treats it as fee splitting.

What is a cost-plus MSO fee?

A fee equal to the MSO's costs of serving the practice plus a markup. It moves with the MSO's costs rather than with the practice's collections. OIG said in 2020 that whether a fee based on actual expenses meets the safe harbor's set-in-advance condition "would depend on the facts and circumstances", so in our reading the cost categories and the markup belong in the signed agreement before any payment, and the fee still has to be consistent with fair market value.

Does the calculator tell me whether my fee is fair market value?

No. Fair market value is a valuation question about what the MSO actually provides and what comparable services cost. OIG's compliance guidance asks whether it rests on "a reasonable methodology that is uniformly applied and properly documented", and an independent valuation is one way to document it.

Can people who are not physicians own an MSO in North Carolina?

They can own the management company. The medical practice is different: the Medical Board's position statement 10.1.2 says a business practicing medicine must be owned in its entirety by holders of active North Carolina licenses, or by a combination G.S. 55B-14 permits, so people without such a license cannot own it, and the MSO provides the business side and leaves medical decisions to the practice. The MSO guide explains the structure.

Cite or embed this tool

Newsletters, associations and reporters are welcome to cite the tool or put it on their own pages. Please credit DPS Law with a link to this page.

Citation

DPS Law, “MSO management fee calculator,” updated November 17, 2026, https://dpslaw.com/tools/mso-management-fee-calculator.

Related

More tools

Published November 17, 2026; updated November 17, 2026. General information and modeling, not legal, tax or investment advice. Using the tool does not create an attorney–client relationship. See the disclaimer.

Drafting or reviewing a management services agreement?

DPS Law drafts and reviews management services agreements for North Carolina practices, including the fee terms. Our attorney is licensed in North Carolina only.

All tools