Healthcare business law · Updated
Who can own a medical practice in New York?
In New York a medical practice is owned only by physicians licensed in New York. A professional service corporation may issue shares only to individuals authorized "to practice in this state" its profession (Business Corporation Law § 1507), and each member of a medical PLLC, like each partner of a medical LLP, "must be licensed pursuant to article 131 of the education law to practice medicine in this state." Owners of a foreign corporation or PLLC that provides health services here need New York licenses too. Physician assistants, nurse practitioners and lay investors cannot be members or partners. A business corporation other than a professional corporation that provides medical services is operating a diagnostic or treatment center, which needs Article 28 approval. And Education Law § 6530(19) treats a percentage-of-income fee for space, equipment or staff as professional misconduct. Checked on November 17, 2026.
DPS Law’s attorney is licensed in North Carolina only. This page summarizes New York law as of November 17, 2026, with the statutes and rules it relies on linked below. It is general information, not legal advice; for a New York matter, talk to a lawyer licensed in New York.
| Who | May own the medical practice? | Where the rule comes from |
|---|---|---|
| Physician licensed in New York | Yes: alone, in a partnership, or as a shareholder of a professional service corporation (P.C.), a member of a PLLC or a partner of a registered LLP. A P.C.'s directors and officers must also be licensed in New York and be shareholders or practice in the corporation | BCL § 1507; BCL § 1508; LLC Law § 1203; Partnership Law § 121-1500(q) |
| Physician licensed only in another state | No. Not in a New York medical P.C., PLLC or LLP, and not in a foreign professional corporation or PLLC that provides health services in New York, whose owners "shall be licensed in this state" | BCL § 1525(d); LLC Law § 1301; LLC Law § 1203 |
| Physician assistant | No. A medical PLLC member or LLP partner must be licensed to practice medicine under article 131; in our reading, the same is true of P.C. shares. A PA performs medical services "only when under the supervision of a physician" | LLC Law § 1203; Education Law § 6542; BCL § 1507 |
| Nurse practitioner | Not a medical practice, for the same reason. In our reading, an NP may own a P.C. or PLLC organized to render NP services; after more than 3,600 hours of practice no written practice agreement with a physician is required | LLC Law § 1203; BCL § 1503(a); Education Law § 6902(3)(b) (version effective until July 1, 2030) |
| Lay investor, business corporation or ordinary LLC | No. Shares issued, voting agreements made or proxies granted in violation of the statute "shall be void". A business corporation other than a P.C. that provides medical services is operating a diagnostic or treatment center | BCL § 1507; Education Law § 6522; 10 NYCRR 600.8(a) (Cornell LII copy) |
| Owners of an Article 28 diagnostic and treatment center | Yes, with the written approval of the Public Health and Health Planning Council, which reviews owners' "character, competence, and standing in the community". For profit, the operator is a natural person, a partnership or an LLC, or a business corporation the council approves; no operator corporation may have stock "owned by another corporation" | PHL § 2801-a(1), (3), (4)(e), (9) |
| Question | New York | Source |
|---|---|---|
| Is there a corporate practice of medicine rule? | Yes, in statute. "Only a person licensed or otherwise authorized under this article shall practice medicine", and aiding or abetting an unlicensed person to practice is a class E felony. The Attorney General described the prohibition in 2014 as barring corporations "from practicing medicine or employing physicians to provide medical services" | Education Law § 6522; § 6512; Attorney General, Sept. 25, 2014 |
| The medical entities | Professional service corporation (BCL article 15), PLLC (LLC Law article 12) or registered LLP; a P.C.'s name ends with "Professional Corporation" or "P.C." | BCL § 1512; LLC Law § 1203; Partnership Law § 121-1500 |
| Filing | The certificate of incorporation attaches a licensing authority certificate for each shareholder, director and officer; the Department of State asks for a Certificate of Authority (Form PLS709) from the Education Department and charges a $125 filing fee | BCL § 1503(b); Department of State |
| Discipline of the entity | A P.C. authorized to practice medicine is subject to the prehearing and hearing procedures for individual physicians in Public Health Law title II-A, the title whose § 230 creates the State Board for Professional Medical Conduct | BCL § 1503(d); PHL § 230 |
| Percentage fees | Professional misconduct when payment for "space, facilities, equipment or personnel services" is "a percentage of, or is otherwise dependent upon" the practice's income or receipts, except for Article 28 and Mental Hygiene Law article 13 facilities | Education Law § 6530(19) |
| Paying for referrals | Professional misconduct to give or receive "any fee or other consideration to or from a third party for the referral of a patient" | Education Law § 6530(18) |
| Self-referral | No referral for clinical laboratory, pharmacy, radiation therapy, physical therapy or x-ray or imaging services to a provider the practitioner has a financial relationship with, subject to exceptions; disclosure for other services | PHL § 238-a; PHL § 238-d |
| Management services organizations (MSOs) | A "health care entity" under the material transactions law: 30 days' notice to the Department of Health before a transaction adding $25 million or more of in-state revenue | PHL § 4550; PHL § 4552 |
| Med spas | No med spa license: "There is no individual NYS agency that licenses providers of med spa services" (January 8, 2026). Office-based surgery requires accreditation | Department of State; PHL § 230-d |
Where New York's rule comes from
New York's rule is written into Education Law § 6522: "Only a person licensed or otherwise authorized under this article shall practice medicine" (§ 6522), and § 6512 makes it a class E felony to practice without a license or to aid or abet "an unlicensed person to practice a profession" (§ 6512). For a physician, "Permitting, aiding or abetting an unlicensed person to perform activities requiring a license" is also professional misconduct (§ 6530(11)). The Department of Health adds an entity rule: medical services provided by a not-for-profit or business corporation "other than professional service corporation shall constitute the operation of a diagnostic or treatment center" (10 NYCRR 600.8(a), Cornell LII copy), a facility that needs approval under Public Health Law article 28.
We found no formal Attorney General opinion on the doctrine; instead, in a September 2014 settlement the office said Correctional Medical Care, which provided health care to jail inmates in 13 counties and whose owner "is not a licensed medical provider", had violated "New York's prohibition of the corporate practice of medicine". The company agreed to "provide only administrative services" and to create "a separate professional medical corporation to provide medical care" (Attorney General, September 25, 2014). In a no-fault auto insurance case against acupuncture professional corporations accused of paying third parties for patient referrals, the Court of Appeals held on November 24, 2025 that the no-fault eligibility regulation does not let an insurer refuse payment for "alleged professional misconduct that falls short of ceding control of a professional services corporation to an unlicensed party", as the Second Circuit quotes the ruling (GEICO v. Mayzenberg, 2d Cir., March 10, 2026). The Court of Appeals' own site refused automated reading on November 17, 2026, so its earlier decisions are not summarized here.
Three entities, all owned by New York-licensed physicians
A New York medical practice can be a professional service corporation (Business Corporation Law article 15), a PLLC (LLC Law article 12) or a registered limited liability partnership (Partnership Law § 121-1500). A P.C. "may issue shares only to individuals who are authorized by law to practice in this state a profession which such corporation is authorized to practice", and no one may be a director or officer unless licensed here and "either a shareholder of such corporation or engaged in the practice of his profession in such corporation" (BCL § 1507; § 1508). For medicine the PLLC and LLP statutes say it outright: each member, and each partner, "must be licensed pursuant to article 131 of the education law to practice medicine in this state" (LLC Law § 1203; Partnership Law § 121-1500(q)). The general PLLC membership rule admits professionals licensed "in any foreign jurisdiction" (LLC Law § 1207(a)(2)), but the medical sentence in § 1203 requires a New York license.
Forming the entity under another state's law does not get around the New York license: all shareholders, directors and officers of a foreign professional service corporation "which provides health services in this state shall be licensed in this state" (BCL § 1525(d)), and all members and managers of a foreign PLLC that provides health services here "shall be licensed in this state" (LLC Law § 1301). A P.C.'s certificate of incorporation must attach a licensing authority certificate "certifying that each of the proposed shareholders, directors and officers is authorized by law to practice" (BCL § 1503(b)); the Department of State asks for a "Certificate of Authority (Form PLS709)" from the Education Department and lists a "$125 filing fee" (Department of State). The corporation answers for misconduct itself: a P.C. authorized to practice medicine is subject to the hearing procedures that apply to individual physicians under Public Health Law title II-A (BCL § 1503(d)).
Physician assistants and nurse practitioners
Neither can own part of a New York medical practice, because New York's PLLC and LLP statutes name the license: each member of a medical PLLC and each partner of a medical LLP must be licensed under article 131 to practice medicine. Education Law § 6542 adds that a physician assistant "may perform medical services, but only when under the supervision of a physician"; "No physician shall employ or supervise more than six physician assistants" in a private practice at one time (Education Law § 6542). In our reading, a PA cannot hold shares of a medical P.C. either, because those go only to individuals authorized to practice the corporation's profession (§ 1507), and only article 131 licensees may practice medicine (§ 6522).
A nurse practitioner's practice "may include the diagnosis of illness and physical conditions" and prescribing, "in collaboration with a licensed physician" under "a written practice agreement" (Education Law § 6902(3)(a)). An NP "practicing for more than three thousand six hundred hours" need not comply with the requirements "relating to collaboration with a physician, a written practice agreement and written practice protocols" (§ 6902(3)(b), in the version the Senate's site marks effective until July 1, 2030). In our reading, an NP may own a P.C. or PLLC organized to render NP services, since licensees of "the same professional service" may organize one (BCL § 1503(a)). Such an entity renders services only "through individuals authorized by law to render such professional services as individuals" (BCL § 1504(a)), so it cannot be the vehicle for a physician's medical practice.
Lay investors, management companies and the percentage-fee rule
A lay investor's route is a management company, and New York guards the practice's votes as well as its shares. No shareholder of a professional corporation may enter into "a voting trust agreement, proxy, or any other type agreement" vesting voting power in anyone but another shareholder or a person eligible to be one, and "All shares issued, agreements made, or proxies granted in violation of this section shall be void" (BCL § 1507); the PLLC statute has the same rule for membership interests (LLC Law § 1207(c)). In our reading, that rules out a management company holding a proxy or voting agreement over the physician owner's shares.
New York's fee rule is statute too. Education Law § 6530(19) makes it professional misconduct to permit "any person to share in the fees for professional services" other than a partner, employee or associate, a "professional subcontractor or consultant authorized to practice medicine" or a supervised trainee, and the prohibition "shall include any arrangement or agreement whereby the amount received in payment for furnishing space, facilities, equipment or personnel services used by a licensee constitutes a percentage of, or is otherwise dependent upon, the income or receipts of the licensee from such practice", except for facilities licensed under Public Health Law article 28 or Mental Hygiene Law article 13 (§ 6530(19)). The Regents' rule for the other professions licensed under title VIII of the Education Law uses nearly the same words (8 NYCRR 29.1(b)(4), Cornell LII copy). In a dental case, enforcing "New York's laws banning the corporate practice of medicine and fee-splitting", the Attorney General said Aspen Dental Management took "a pre-set percentage of each dental office's monthly gross profit, an arrangement prohibited under New York law", and the company agreed "not to share in the dental practices' fees for professional services rendered" (Attorney General, June 18, 2015).
Giving or receiving "any fee or other consideration to or from a third party for the referral of a patient" is misconduct under § 6530(18). Public Health Law § 238-a bars a practitioner from referring clinical laboratory, pharmacy, radiation therapy, physical therapy or x-ray or imaging services to a provider with which the practitioner has a "financial relationship", and its bar on billing reaches "any individual or third party payor" (§ 238-a). And a management services organization "providing all or substantially all of the administrative or management services under contract with one or more physician practices" is a "health care entity" that must notify the Department of Health at least thirty days before closing a material transaction, one that raises its in-state revenue by $25 million or more (PHL § 4550; § 4552).
Clinics and med spas: Article 28 and the 2026 inspections
Because a business corporation that provides medical services is operating a diagnostic or treatment center, Article 28 is, in our reading, the route for a lay-owned clinic. The statute's "hospital" includes a "diagnostic center" and a "treatment center" (PHL § 2801), and none may be established "except with the written approval of the public health and health planning council", which reviews the "character, competence, and standing in the community" of the proposed incorporators, directors, sponsors, stockholders, members or operators. "Only a natural person, a partnership or limited liability company" may operate one for profit, apart from a business corporation the council approves and older exceptions for hospitals operating in 1956 and for nursing homes; no operator may be a corporation "any of the stock of which is owned by another corporation"; and a transfer of ten percent or more of the stock or voting rights needs approval (PHL § 2801-a). The Department of Health's rule also makes it "prima facie evidence" that a center is being operated when a provider describes itself as a "center," "clinic" or "by any name other than the name of one or more of the practitioners" (10 NYCRR 600.8(b)), while the definition of a center leaves out "the individual or group private practice of medicine" (10 NYCRR 751.1).
After inspections with the Department of Health and the Education Department, the Department of State said on January 8, 2026 that "There is no individual NYS agency that licenses providers of med spa services"; "In total, 223 businesses have been inspected" and 87 "were cited for possible violations". The same release says a business promoting itself as a med spa "MUST be licensed as a medical facility and licensed professionals must be performing the services", lists injections, "Laser procedures (except for laser hair removal)", microneedling and IV therapy among medical procedures, and says such facilities usually have a medical director "who is a licensed physician or nurse practitioner in good standing" (Department of State). A practice where procedures are performed under general anesthesia, moderate or deep sedation, or liposuction beyond the minor-procedure limit must hold "full accredited status" (PHL § 230-d). In our reading, that leaves the medical side of a New York med spa two homes: a P.C., PLLC or LLP owned by New York-licensed physicians and trading under a name that does not trigger 10 NYCRR 600.8(b), or an Article 28 center the council has approved; a company owned by lay investors can supply only non-medical services.
How New York compares with North Carolina
North Carolina keeps lay owners out through a Medical Board position statement; New York does it through the Education Law and its entity statutes. Where North Carolina's Board accepts owners holding "active North Carolina licenses" or "one of the combinations permitted in N.C. Gen. Stat. § 55B-14", and says it "may seek injunctive relief against lay owners of businesses" (NCMB position statement 10.1.2, amended September 2025), New York's statutes allow no mixed-license combination in a medical PLLC or LLP, and aiding unlicensed practice is a class E felony under Education Law § 6512.
On fees, North Carolina's Board says "a licensee cannot share revenue on a percentage basis with a non-licensee" (NCMB position statement 10.1.1, amended September 2021). New York's § 6530(19) is a statute, it reaches payments "otherwise dependent upon" the practice's income as well as percentages, and it excepts Article 28 and Mental Hygiene Law article 13 facilities by name. Two New York features have no counterpart in the North Carolina Board statements quoted here: state approval for any clinic a business corporation runs, and a 30-day notice to the Department of Health before a management company's material transaction (North Carolina's side of these questions is set out in who can own a med spa in North Carolina).
Check a management fee for a New York practice
Compare a flat fee, cost plus a markup and a percentage of collections, and see which New York and federal rules bear on the one you are considering. The figures stay in your browser.
What the rules say about this structure
New York rules
Education Law § 6530(19): a percentage fee for space, equipment or staff is misconduct
Education Law § 6530(19) makes it professional misconduct to permit "any person to share in the fees for professional services" other than a partner, employee, associate, "professional subcontractor or consultant authorized to practice medicine" or supervised trainee. This "shall include any arrangement or agreement whereby the amount received in payment for furnishing space, facilities, equipment or personnel services" used by a licensee "constitutes a percentage of, or is otherwise dependent upon, the income or receipts" of the practice, except for facilities licensed under Public Health Law article 28 or Mental Hygiene Law article 13. In our reading, a management fee set as a percentage of a New York P.C.'s or PLLC's collections is the arrangement those words describe.[1]
New York: a flat or cost-plus fee must not move with the practice's receipts
Section 6530(19) reaches a payment for space, equipment or staff that is a percentage of the practice's income "or is otherwise dependent upon" it. In our reading, a flat or cost-plus fee is outside those words only while it does not rise or fall with collections, so a bonus, tier or year-end true-up tied to revenue would bring it back in. In a dental case the Attorney General said Aspen Dental Management took "a pre-set percentage of each dental office's monthly gross profit, an arrangement prohibited under New York law"; the company agreed "not to share in the dental practices' fees for professional services rendered" (June 18, 2015).[1][22]
New York: no lay shares, proxies or voting agreements, and no ceded control
A medical professional corporation issues shares only to New York-licensed physicians, and no shareholder may give anyone but another shareholder or an eligible licensee "a voting trust agreement, proxy, or any other type agreement" vesting voting power; such shares, agreements and proxies "shall be void" (BCL § 1507; LLC Law § 1207(c) for PLLCs). In 2014 the Attorney General required Correctional Medical Care, whose owner "is not a licensed medical provider", to "provide only administrative services". For no-fault claims, the Court of Appeals held in November 2025 that an insurer may not refuse payment for misconduct "that falls short of ceding control of a professional services corporation to an unlicensed party" (as the Second Circuit quotes it).[6][9][21][23]
Education Law § 6530(18): no fee for the referral of a patient
A physician commits professional misconduct by "Directly or indirectly offering, giving, soliciting, or receiving or agreeing to receive, any fee or other consideration to or from a third party for the referral of a patient or in connection with the performance of professional services" (§ 6530(18)); 8 NYCRR 29.1(b)(3) uses nearly the same words for other licensees. For Medicaid business, Social Services Law § 366-d also bars payment "for the referral of services": a misdemeanor, and a class E felony when more than $7,500 is obtained. In our reading, a per-patient marketing fee falls within § 6530(18), while a fixed advertising fee that does not vary with the patients produced is not a fee "for the referral of a patient".[1][4][18]
Public Health Law § 238-a: self-referral bar for lab, pharmacy, imaging, PT and radiation therapy
A practitioner who orders clinical laboratory, pharmacy, radiation therapy, physical therapy or x-ray or imaging services "may not make a referral for such services" to a provider with which the practitioner or an immediate family member has a "financial relationship": "an ownership interest, investment interest or compensation arrangement" (Public Health Law §§ 238, 238-a). No claim may be presented "to any individual or third party payor" for a prohibited referral, so the bar is not limited to Medicaid. Exceptions include group practice and in-office ancillary services, and § 238-d requires disclosure for other services. In our reading, this matters when the management company's owners also own a lab, pharmacy or imaging business the practice uses.[15][16][17]
Public Health Law article 45-A: MSOs give notice of material transactions
New York's material transactions law names as a "health care entity" a physician practice and a "management services organization or similar entity providing all or substantially all of the administrative or management services under contract with one or more physician practices" (Public Health Law § 4550). A health care entity must give the Department of Health written notice at least thirty days before closing a merger, acquisition, affiliation agreement or other transaction the statute lists that raises its in-state revenue by $25 million or more, and failure to notify carries civil penalties, each day a separate violation (§ 4552). The Senate's site shows these sections last revised August 4, 2023; the Department's own guidance could not be read (HTTP 403).[19][20]
New York statutes (nysenate.gov), Regents and Department of Health rules (Cornell LII copies), Attorney General releases and a Second Circuit opinion that bear on a management fee between a New York practice and a management company, read on November 17, 2026; the federal rules show for every state.
Sources for the New York notes
- N.Y. Education Law § 6530(11), (18) and (19), definitions of professional misconduct (nysenate.gov, revision of Aug. 7, 2026) (as of November 17, 2026)
- N.Y. Education Law § 6522, practice of medicine and use of title "physician" (nysenate.gov) (as of November 17, 2026)
- N.Y. Education Law § 6512, unauthorized practice a crime (nysenate.gov) (as of November 17, 2026)
- 8 NYCRR 29.1(b)(3) and (4), Regents rules on unprofessional conduct (Cornell LII copy; op.nysed.gov failed a certificate check) (as of November 17, 2026)
- N.Y. Business Corporation Law § 1503, organization of professional service corporations (nysenate.gov, revision of July 26, 2024) (as of November 17, 2026)
- N.Y. Business Corporation Law § 1507, issuance of shares (nysenate.gov, revision of July 26, 2024) (as of November 17, 2026)
- N.Y. Business Corporation Law § 1525(d), foreign professional service corporations (nysenate.gov, revision of June 14, 2024) (as of November 17, 2026)
- N.Y. Limited Liability Company Law § 1203, formation of professional service LLCs (nysenate.gov) (as of November 17, 2026)
- N.Y. Limited Liability Company Law § 1207, membership of professional service LLCs (nysenate.gov, revision of June 14, 2024) (as of November 17, 2026)
- N.Y. Limited Liability Company Law § 1301, foreign professional service LLCs (nysenate.gov) (as of November 17, 2026)
- N.Y. Partnership Law § 121-1500, registered limited liability partnerships (nysenate.gov) (as of November 17, 2026)
- N.Y. Public Health Law § 2801-a, establishment of Article 28 facilities (nysenate.gov, revision of Dec. 26, 2025) (as of November 17, 2026)
- N.Y. Public Health Law § 230, State Board for Professional Medical Conduct (nysenate.gov) (as of November 17, 2026)
- 10 NYCRR 600.8, operation of a diagnostic or treatment center (Cornell LII copy; regs.health.ny.gov returned HTTP 403) (as of November 17, 2026)
- N.Y. Public Health Law § 238, definitions for practitioner referrals (nysenate.gov) (as of November 17, 2026)
- N.Y. Public Health Law § 238-a, prohibition of financial arrangements and referrals (nysenate.gov) (as of November 17, 2026)
- N.Y. Public Health Law § 238-d, practitioner disclosure requirements (nysenate.gov) (as of November 17, 2026)
- N.Y. Social Services Law § 366-d, medical assistance provider prohibited practices (nysenate.gov) (as of November 17, 2026)
- N.Y. Public Health Law § 4550, material transactions definitions (nysenate.gov, revision of Aug. 4, 2023) (as of November 17, 2026)
- N.Y. Public Health Law § 4552, notice of material transactions (nysenate.gov, revision of Aug. 4, 2023) (as of November 17, 2026)
- New York Attorney General, settlement with Correctional Medical Care (Sept. 25, 2014) (as of November 17, 2026)
- New York Attorney General, settlement with Aspen Dental Management (June 18, 2015) (as of November 17, 2026)
- Government Employees Insurance Co. v. Mayzenberg, No. 22-2537 (2d Cir. Mar. 10, 2026), quoting the Court of Appeals' answer of Nov. 24, 2025 (govinfo.gov) (as of November 17, 2026)
Federal rules
The Anti-Kickback Statute reaches federal program business
The federal Anti-Kickback Statute makes it a felony to knowingly and willfully offer, pay, solicit or receive any remuneration to induce, or in return for, referrals or the arranging for or recommending of items or services for which payment may be made in whole or in part under a federal health care program. The criminal maximum is a $100,000 fine and 10 years in prison, and OIG may also impose a civil penalty of up to $127,973 per act, the 2025 level that HHS kept for 2026. A management fee is protected by the personal services and management contracts safe harbor only if it meets every condition, but OIG says failing one "does not render an arrangement automatically illegal"; the arrangement is then reviewed on "the totality of the facts and circumstances, including the intent of the parties."[1][2][3][4][5][7]
Signed writing, every service listed, one-year term
The safe harbor requires the agreement to be "set out in writing and signed by the parties", to cover and specify all of the services the MSO provides to the practice for the term, and to run for "not less than 1 year." OIG has said the writing can be one signed agreement or a signed collection of documents that together contain every required element. Its compliance guidance also asks whether the parties document the services they provide and whether arrangements "are actually conducted according to the terms of the written agreements."[5][6][7]
Fair market value and commercial reasonableness
The fee methodology must be "consistent with fair market value in arm's-length transactions", and the services contracted for may not exceed those "reasonably necessary to accomplish the commercially reasonable business purpose of the services." OIG has declined to define either term for the Anti-Kickback Statute and is barred by statute from opining on fair market value in an advisory opinion, so the figures in this estimator are not a fair market value finding. OIG's compliance guidance asks, "Is the determination of fair market value based upon a reasonable methodology that is uniformly applied and properly documented?", and in Advisory Opinion 25-03 the requestors certified each fee as consistent with fair market value "as established by a reputable, independent third-party valuator."[5][6][7][11]
A fixed fee is set in advance
A fixed fee for a written list of services is a compensation methodology set in advance, and because it does not change with the number of patients or the practice's collections, it does not move with referrals or business generated between the parties. In Advisory Opinion 25-03, OIG concluded that fees a practice would pay to a management services organization and the telehealth practice it manages would not generate prohibited remuneration, where the requestors certified that the fee methodology would be set in advance and consistent with fair market value, noting that paying the hourly fee "regardless of whether" the practice was reimbursed "decreases the likelihood" that the fee takes into account the volume or value of referrals or business generated between the parties. An advisory opinion protects only the parties that requested it, and a fixed fee still has to be consistent with fair market value for the services actually provided.[5][11]
Percentage fee and the volume-or-value condition
Since January 19, 2021, the safe harbor requires the compensation methodology, rather than the total amount, to be set in advance, so, in our reading, a percentage fixed in the signed agreement is not ruled out on that ground alone. The harder condition is that the methodology may not take into account "the volume or value of any referrals or business otherwise generated between the parties" that federal programs pay for, and a fee measured by collections rises with that business whenever the MSO or its owners help generate it. In 1998 OIG said percentage compensation for marketing services "may implicate" the statute and stated a "longstanding concern that percentage billing arrangements may increase the risk of upcoding and similar abusive billing practices." Missing the safe harbor is not itself a violation; the arrangement is then judged on its facts, including intent.[5][6][8][9][7]
Cost-plus: costs and markup fixed before payment
OIG said in its 2020 rule that an arrangement can fit the safe harbor "by using an hourly rate or other set, verifiable formula", but that whether an employee lease paid on "actual expenses incurred" meets the set-in-advance condition "would depend on the facts and circumstances." Parties must determine "whether the compensation methodology over the term of the agreement is set in advance before any payment under the arrangement is made", which in our reading means the cost categories, the markup and the way costs are verified belong in the signed agreement. OIG's example was that a bonus taking into account referrals between the parties, passed through as a cost, would leave the compensation unprotected, and the markup is part of the compensation that must be consistent with fair market value.[6][5]
Paying the MSO to bring in patients
The Anti-Kickback Statute reaches payment for "arranging for or recommending" federally payable items or services, not only for direct referrals, and OIG said in 1998 that percentage compensation for marketing services "may implicate" the statute. In 2022 OIG described a per-patient-encounter fee as a "per-click" fee structure, which "generally is inherently reflective of the volume or value of referrals or business otherwise generated between the parties." Measured against the safe harbor, a marketing fee fixed in advance for defined advertising work does not vary with the patients generated; a percentage or per-patient fee does.[1][8][10][5]
Fees between parties who refer to each other
When the MSO's owners or affiliates and the practice refer patients to each other, the management fee runs between parties who can generate federal program business for each other. OIG's compliance guidance asks, "Is the entity paying an inflated rate to a potential referral source?" and whether a party is "receiving free or below-market-rate items or services", so the fee can be questioned whether it sits above or below fair market value. The safe harbor also excludes a methodology that takes into account "the volume or value of any referrals or business otherwise generated between the parties"; a percentage of collections rises with the patients the owners send, while a fixed fee does not.[7][5]
Stark: physician owners and designated health services
Stark bars a physician who has a financial relationship with an entity, an ownership interest or a compensation arrangement, directly or through an immediate family member, from referring Medicare patients to it for designated health services such as clinical laboratory, radiology and imaging, physical therapy and outpatient prescription drugs, and bars the entity from billing for them, unless an exception applies. The entity is the one that performs or bills those services, usually the practice or an affiliate rather than a management-only MSO, and an ownership interest can run through an entity that owns the provider. Each element of an exception must be met; the personal service arrangements exception, for example, requires a signed writing specifying the services, a term of at least 1 year, and compensation "set in advance" that "does not exceed fair market value" and is not determined in any manner that takes into account "the volume or value of referrals or other business generated between the parties."[12][13][14]
General information for modeling management fee structures, not legal advice; whether a fee is consistent with fair market value is a question for a documented valuation of the services, not a calculator.
Sources for the federal notes
- 42 U.S.C. 1320a-7b(b), the Anti-Kickback Statute (uscode.house.gov, current through Pub. L. 119-124) (as of November 17, 2026)
- 42 U.S.C. 1320a-7a(a)(7), civil money penalty for kickbacks (uscode.house.gov, current through Pub. L. 119-124) (as of November 17, 2026)
- 45 CFR 102.3, inflation-adjusted civil money penalties (eCFR, up to date as of Nov. 13, 2026) (as of November 17, 2026)
- HHS, No Adjustment to HHS Civil Monetary Penalty Amounts for 2026, 91 FR 66566 (Oct. 21, 2026) (as of November 17, 2026)
- 42 CFR 1001.952(d), personal services and management contracts safe harbor (eCFR, up to date as of Nov. 13, 2026) (as of November 17, 2026)
- OIG final rule amending the safe harbors, 85 FR 77684 (Dec. 2, 2020; effective Jan. 19, 2021) (as of November 17, 2026)
- HHS-OIG, General Compliance Program Guidance (Nov. 6, 2023) (as of November 17, 2026)
- HHS-OIG Advisory Opinion No. 98-4 (Apr. 15, 1998): management company paid costs plus a percentage of practice revenue (as of November 17, 2026)
- HHS-OIG, Compliance Program Guidance for Third-Party Medical Billing Companies, 63 FR 70138 (Dec. 18, 1998; listed in OIG's CPG archive) (as of November 17, 2026)
- HHS-OIG Advisory Opinion No. 22-09 (Apr. 25, 2022): per-patient-encounter fees (as of November 17, 2026)
- HHS-OIG Advisory Opinion No. 25-03 (June 6, 2025): fees to telehealth management services organizations (as of November 17, 2026)
- 42 U.S.C. 1395nn, physician self-referral (Stark) law (uscode.house.gov, current through Pub. L. 119-124) (as of November 17, 2026)
- 42 CFR 411.351, Stark definitions, including entity (eCFR, up to date as of Nov. 13, 2026) (as of November 17, 2026)
- 42 CFR 411.357(d), Stark personal service arrangements exception (eCFR, up to date as of Nov. 13, 2026) (as of November 17, 2026)
Compare New York with other states
Each colored state has its own page, read at that state's own sources.
- Lay investors may not own the medical practice
- Some forms barred, no broader rule found
- Lay ownership possible in some form
- Covered: read the details
- Not covered yet
Common questions
Can a non-doctor own a medical practice in New York?
No. Shares of a medical professional corporation go only to individuals authorized to practice medicine in New York, and voting agreements or proxies in favor of anyone else "shall be void" (BCL § 1507). In our reading, a non-physician can own a management company that provides only administrative services to the practice, the structure the Attorney General required of Correctional Medical Care in 2014, or, with the Public Health and Health Planning Council's approval, an Article 28 diagnostic and treatment center (PHL § 2801-a).
Can a nurse practitioner own a medical practice in New York?
Not a medical one: each member of a medical PLLC must be licensed to practice medicine in New York (LLC Law § 1203). An NP with more than 3,600 hours of practice may practice without a written practice agreement (Education Law § 6902(3)(b), version effective until July 1, 2030), and in our reading may own a P.C. or PLLC for NP services, which cannot offer a physician's services.
Can a physician licensed in another state own part of a New York medical practice?
No. A New York P.C. issues shares only to individuals authorized to practice "in this state", and the owners of a foreign professional corporation or PLLC that provides health services in New York "shall be licensed in this state" (BCL § 1525(d); LLC Law § 1301).
Can a management company charge a percentage of collections in New York?
Education Law § 6530(19) makes it professional misconduct when payment for "space, facilities, equipment or personnel services" is "a percentage of, or is otherwise dependent upon, the income or receipts" of the practice, unless the facility is licensed under Public Health Law article 28 or Mental Hygiene Law article 13. In our reading, a percentage-of-collections management fee paid by a physician practice falls within those words.
Does a med spa need a license in New York?
Not a med spa license as such: the Department of State said on January 8, 2026 that "There is no individual NYS agency that licenses providers of med spa services". The same release says a business promoting med spa services "MUST be licensed as a medical facility", and it lists injections, laser procedures other than hair removal, microneedling and IV therapy among "cosmetic procedures that require a medical license to perform".
Can a New York practice call itself a clinic?
Carefully. A Department of Health rule makes it "prima facie evidence" that a diagnostic or treatment center is being operated when a provider describes itself as a "center," "clinic" or by any name other than the name of one or more of its practitioners (10 NYCRR 600.8(b)), and such a center needs Article 28 approval.
Update log
- November 17, 2026. Published. Covers New York's statutory corporate practice rule, the three medical entities and their New York-license requirement (including foreign entities), physician assistants and nurse practitioners, the Education Law § 6530(19) percentage-fee rule, Article 28 clinics, the material transactions law and the January 2026 med spa inspections. Read at the source November 17, 2026: the Education, Business Corporation, LLC, Partnership and Public Health Law sections cited (nysenate.gov), 10 NYCRR 600.8 and 751.1 and 8 NYCRR 29.1 (Cornell LII copies, because regs.health.ny.gov returned HTTP 403 and op.nysed.gov failed a certificate check), the Attorney General's 2014 and 2015 releases, the Second Circuit's March 10, 2026 opinion (govinfo.gov), the Department of State's pages and the NC Medical Board's position statements. The Court of Appeals' site (nycourts.gov) and the Department of Health's site (health.ny.gov) returned HTTP 403, so court opinions are described only as the Second Circuit quotes them and the Department's material transactions guidance is not covered.
Sources
- N.Y. Education Law § 6522, practice of medicine and use of title "physician" (nysenate.gov)
- N.Y. Education Law § 6512, unauthorized practice a crime (nysenate.gov)
- N.Y. Education Law § 6530, definitions of professional misconduct, including (11), (18) and (19) (nysenate.gov, revision of Aug. 7, 2026)
- N.Y. Education Law § 6542, performance of medical services by physician assistants (nysenate.gov, revision of May 29, 2026)
- N.Y. Education Law § 6902, definition of practice of nursing (nysenate.gov, revision of May 29, 2026)
- N.Y. Business Corporation Law §§ 1503, 1504, 1507, 1508 and 1512, professional service corporations (nysenate.gov)
- N.Y. Business Corporation Law § 1525, foreign professional service corporations: definitions (nysenate.gov)
- N.Y. Limited Liability Company Law §§ 1203 and 1207, professional service LLCs (nysenate.gov)
- N.Y. Limited Liability Company Law § 1301, foreign professional service LLCs: definitions (nysenate.gov)
- N.Y. Partnership Law § 121-1500, registered limited liability partnerships (nysenate.gov)
- N.Y. Public Health Law §§ 2801 and 2801-a, Article 28 facilities and their establishment (nysenate.gov)
- N.Y. Public Health Law §§ 238, 238-a and 238-d, practitioner self-referral (nysenate.gov)
- N.Y. Public Health Law §§ 4550 and 4552, disclosure of material transactions (nysenate.gov, revision of Aug. 4, 2023)
- N.Y. Public Health Law § 230-d, office-based surgery (nysenate.gov)
- 10 NYCRR 600.8, criteria for operation of a diagnostic or treatment center (Cornell LII copy)
- 10 NYCRR 751.1, definition of diagnostic and treatment center (Cornell LII copy)
- 8 NYCRR 29.1, Regents rules on unprofessional conduct (Cornell LII copy)
- New York Attorney General, settlement with Correctional Medical Care (Sept. 25, 2014)
- New York Attorney General, settlement with Aspen Dental Management (June 18, 2015)
- Government Employees Insurance Co. v. Mayzenberg, No. 22-2537 (2d Cir. Mar. 10, 2026), quoting the Court of Appeals' answer of Nov. 24, 2025 (govinfo.gov)
- New York Department of State, warning to consumers after investigations of med spa service providers (Jan. 8, 2026)
- New York Department of State, Certificate of Incorporation (Professional Service) for domestic corporations
- NC Medical Board, Corporate Practice of Medicine, position statement 10.1.2 (adopted Mar. 2016, amended Sept. 2025)
- NC Medical Board, Referral Fees and Fee Splitting, position statement 10.1.1 (adopted Nov. 1993, amended Sept. 2021)
Related
Building a practice, MSO or med spa that reaches into New York?
DPS Law structures North Carolina medical practices, med spas and the management companies that serve them.