Healthcare business law · Updated
Who can own a medical practice in Idaho?
Idaho's Board of Medicine says of elective-care businesses: "some are owned by health care professionals such as nurses and physicians, and others by aestheticians or business professionals" (September 2025). Nothing we could read in its rules, the Secretary of State's entity forms or the Attorney General's reports since 1975 states a corporate practice of medicine doctrine; the Idaho Code and Supreme Court opinions could not be read. In our reading, Idaho's limits fall on the licensee: allowing "another person or organization" to use a license is a ground for discipline, and a supervising physician's duties "may not be transferred to a business entity, professional corporation, or partnership." Medicine and nursing may form professional corporations and PLLCs under Title 30, Chapter 21. In 1989 the Attorney General's office found a 9% gross revenue fee paid to a preferred provider organization for its services was not fee splitting under § 54-1814(8).
DPS Law’s attorney is licensed in North Carolina only. This page summarizes Idaho law as of November 18, 2026, with the statutes and rules it relies on linked below. It is general information, not legal advice; for a Idaho matter, talk to a lawyer licensed in Idaho.
| Who | May own the medical practice? | Where the rule comes from |
|---|---|---|
| Physician (MD or DO) licensed in Idaho | Yes, alone or with other physicians, including through a professional corporation or PLLC organized for the practice of medicine | Secretary of State professional corporation form and PLLC form, citing Idaho Code 30-21-901(b) |
| Advanced practice registered nurse, including a nurse practitioner | Yes, in our reading, for care within the APRN's own license. The Board of Nursing calls the APRN "a licensed independent practitioner", and nursing is one of the professions a professional corporation or PLLC may be formed for | IDAPA 24.34.01.200.04.a; PLLC form |
| Physician assistant | Not addressed by any Idaho source we read. A PA may practice only under a written collaborative practice agreement with at least one Idaho-licensed physician, unless employed by a facility with credentialing and privileging systems. The Secretary of State's list of professions does not name physician assistants separately | Board of Medicine collaborative practice FAQ; IDAPA 24.33.02.200.01 |
| Physicians and nurse practitioners in one professional entity | Not settled by the sources we could read. The PLLC form asks for "the principal profession or professions for which members are duly licensed"; the statute itself could not be read on November 18, 2026 | PLLC form (revised January 2019) |
| Investor who is not a licensee, as an owner of a professional corporation or PLLC | No, in our reading. The PLLC form describes members licensed for the entity's profession, and the 1977 statute, as the Attorney General quoted it, allowed as shareholders "only natural persons who themselves are duly licensed" | PLLC form; AG Op. 77-23 (March 23, 1977) |
| Business owned by people who are not licensees, such as an aesthetics, IV hydration or weight-loss clinic | No Idaho rule found that bars it. The Board of Medicine describes these businesses and holds the physicians who prescribe for them to the Medical Practice Act and its rules | Board of Medicine, The Report, September 2025; IDAPA 24.33.01.300.03.c |
| Management company owned by investors | Not the practice, but it may be paid for its services. In 1989 the Attorney General's office found a service fee of 9% of gross revenue "relatively small" and "reasonably related to the services provided", and not fee splitting | AG legal guideline, July 12, 1989, 1989 Annual Report pp. 158 to 160 |
| Question | Idaho | Source |
|---|---|---|
| Is there a corporate practice of medicine rule? | None found in a statute, Board rule, Attorney General opinion or court decision we could read. The Idaho Code on the Legislature's site and the Idaho Supreme Court's opinions could not be read automatically on November 18, 2026 | Our search of the sources on this page |
| Professional entity statute | Title 30, Chapter 21, Idaho Code, with chapter 29 for a professional service corporation and chapter 25 for a PLLC. Section 30-21-901(b) lists the professions, including medicine and nursing, "and no others" | Professional corporation form; PLLC form (both revised January 2019) |
| Entity names and filing | A professional corporation's name must include "chartered", "professional association" or "professional corporation", or P.A., P.C. or Chtd. (30-21-302(a)); a PLLC's must include Professional Limited Liability Company, Professional Limited Company, P.L.L.C. or PLLC (30-21-301). Filing a paper form costs $120 | Professional corporation form; PLLC form |
| What a professional corporation may do | Under the 1977 act, render its professional services, own property needed for them and passively invest its funds, but not "actively engage in any other business" unrelated to those services | AG Op. 77-23 |
| Dividing fees | Idaho Code 54-1814(8), as quoted in 1989, lists as a ground for discipline "Division of fees or gifts or agreement to split or divide fees or gifts received for professional services with any person, institution or corporation in exchange for referral" | AG legal guideline, July 12, 1989 |
| Percentage fees | A physician's fee of 9% of gross revenue from a preferred provider organization's members, paid for its "sales, marketing, advertising, training and consulting", was not fee splitting (1989). The current text of 54-1814 could not be read on November 18, 2026 | AG legal guideline, July 12, 1989 |
| Lending a license | A ground for discipline: "Allowing another person or organization to use his or her license or permit to practice his or her profession" | IDAPA 24.33.01.300.03.c |
| Med spas and cosmetic treatments | No facility license or registration found. The supervising physician records an evaluation before the first treatment, is "on-site or immediately available", and may supervise no more than three medical personnel giving cosmetic treatments at once (six on a petition the Board approves) | IDAPA 24.33.01.200.04 (effective July 1, 2025) |
| The title "medical director" | Not recognized in the practice acts or board rules of the Boards of Medicine, Nursing, Pharmacy, Dentistry, or Barbers and Cosmetology Services, which refer to supervising providers instead | Lifestyle injectables guidance (adopted March 13, 2026) |
| Clinics that send medication home | Register with the Board of Pharmacy as a Prescriber Drug Outlet; not required when treatments are only given in the clinic | Board of Medicine, The Report, September 2025 |
Where Idaho's rule comes from, and what we could not find
No corporate practice of medicine doctrine appears in anything we read for Idaho: the Board of Medicine's rules (IDAPA 24.33.01 and 24.33.02, as published June 12, 2026), its newsletters from March 2025 to September 2026, the Secretary of State's professional entity forms, and the Attorney General's annual reports from 1975 through 2025 (the cumulative indexes for 1975 to 1999 and the full reports since). Two sources could not be read automatically on November 18, 2026: the Idaho Code on the Legislature's site, which did not accept connections, and the Idaho Supreme Court's opinions (HTTP 403). So Title 30, Chapter 21 and sections 54-1807A, 54-1814 and 67-9407 appear on this page only as the Secretary of State, the Attorney General, the Board of Medicine and the licensing division quote or cite them.
The Board of Medicine has looked at the question from the business side. Its September 2025 newsletter says the business models of clinics offering elective care vary: "some are owned by health care professionals such as nurses and physicians, and others by aestheticians or business professionals," and those offering "prescription weight loss injections, IV hydration, and botulinum toxin injections often hire medical directors to prescribe these treatments" (The Report, September 2025). The Board did not call that model unlawful. It told physicians to follow the Medical Practice Act and IDAPA 24.33.01, and said "Allowing another person or organization to use a physician's license or permit to practice their own profession is grounds for discipline."
The Board's rules put the weight on the physician. Its list of grounds for discipline includes "Allowing another person or organization to use his or her license or permit to practice his or her profession" and "Employing, supervising, directing, aiding, or abetting a person not licensed or permitted in this state who directly or indirectly performs activities or provides services requiring a license or permit" (IDAPA 24.33.01.300.03.c, 300.04.e). A physician who supervises medical personnel "accepts full responsibility for all treatments provided by medical personnel", and those duties "may not be transferred to a business entity, professional corporation, or partnership" (IDAPA 24.33.01.200.04.b and b.vii). In our reading, Idaho's rules ask less who owns the clinic than whether an Idaho physician, not the business, makes and answers for each medical decision.
Professional corporations and PLLCs under Title 30, Chapter 21
Idaho forms professional entities under Title 30, Chapter 21 of the Idaho Code: the Secretary of State's professional corporation form cites chapters 21 and 29, and its PLLC form chapters 21 and 25. Only listed professions may use the forms: "architecture, chiropractic, dentistry, engineering, landscape architecture, law, medicine, nursing, occupational therapy, optometry, physical therapy, podiatry, professional geology, psychology, certified or licensed public accountancy, social work, surveying and veterinary medicine, and no others" (Idaho Code 30-21-901(b), as the PLLC form lists it). A professional corporation's name must include "chartered", "professional association" or "professional corporation", or P.A., P.C. or Chtd. (form, citing 30-21-302(a)). Filing either form on paper costs $120.
The PLLC form asks for "the principal profession or professions for which members are duly licensed or otherwise legally authorized to render professional services". The statute that says who may hold an interest could not be read today, so the most detailed official reading we found is older. In Opinion 77-23 (March 23, 1977), the Attorney General quoted the Professional Service Corporation Act, then Idaho Code 30-1303(2), as allowing as shareholders "only natural persons who themselves are duly licensed or otherwise legally authorized within the state of Idaho to render the same professional service as the corporation", and concluded that a professional corporation "may not actively engage in any other business which is unrelated to the rendering of professional services", though it may own property needed for its services and passively invest its funds (AG Op. 77-23). In our reading, an Idaho professional entity for medicine is a vehicle for licensees, and if the current chapter keeps the 1977 purpose limit, the physicians' professional corporation should not also be the management business.
Nurse practitioners and physician assistants
Idaho's Board of Nursing rule states "The advanced practice registered nurse is a licensed independent practitioner" (IDAPA 24.34.01.200.04.a), and the same section makes the APRN responsible for "the assessment, diagnosis and management of patient conditions", including prescribing (200.04.e). Nursing also sits beside medicine on the 30-21-901(b) list of professions that may form a professional corporation or PLLC. In our reading, an Idaho nurse practitioner may hold a nursing professional entity and run a practice within that APRN scope, and no Idaho source we read requires a physician owner or supervisor for that care.
Physician assistants work under a collaboration model that took effect July 1, 2021. The Board of Medicine's FAQ says that, from that date, "before a PA or graduate PA can practice, that individual must have a written collaborative practice agreement in place with at least one collaborating physician", unless the PA is employed by "a facility with credentialing and privileging systems", whose bylaws and procedures then govern (FAQ, citing Idaho Code 54-1807A). The agreement names the parties, the PA's authorized scope and any monitoring parameters (IDAPA 24.33.02.200.01), and every party must be licensed in Idaho. The Board's June 2026 newsletter, discussing PAs whom an organized medical staff oversees, quotes Idaho Code 54-1807A: "The degree and nature of collaboration shall be determined by the facility or practice" (The Report, June 2026).
Neither the PA rules (IDAPA 24.33.02) nor the Board's collaborative practice FAQ says whether a PA may own a practice or hold an interest in a professional entity, and the 30-21-901(b) list, as the Secretary of State prints it, does not name physician assistants separately. In our reading, a PA-owned practice would still need a collaborating physician for each PA outside a credentialing facility, and which entity may hold the PA's interest is a question for Idaho counsel.
Management companies and percentage fees: the 1989 guideline
Idaho's Attorney General has addressed a percentage service fee directly. On July 12, 1989, answering Representative Thomas L. Morrison, the office considered a hearing-services preferred provider organization whose physicians agreed to pay it "a monthly service fee equal to nine percent (9%) of the Gross Revenue" earned from the organization's members. The question was whether that fee violated Idaho Code 54-1814(8), which, as the letter quotes it, lists as a ground for physician discipline "Division of fees or gifts or agreement to split or divide fees or gifts received for professional services with any person, institution or corporation in exchange for referral" (AG legal guideline, July 12, 1989, 1989 Annual Report pp. 158 to 160).
The answer was no. The organization was paid for its "sales, marketing, advertising, training and consulting endeavors", so "the service fee is not paid in exchange for referral of patients", and the 9% fee "is relatively small and appears reasonably related to the services provided by NHS to the physician provider." The letter also cited the view that fee-splitting risk "can be minimized if the percentage or flat fee represents the reasonable value of legitimate services rendered".
The letter has limits. It is an informal legal guideline, which the Attorney General's annual reports publish apart from formal opinions. It read 54-1814(8) as the statute stood in 1989; the current section could not be read today, and the Board's June 2026 newsletter says House Bill 703, effective July 1, 2026, "removes repetitive or inconsistent language across practice acts regarding discipline" (The Report, June 2026). And the fee it accepted was small and tied to services. In our reading, an Idaho management fee set as a percentage of collections fits the letter's reasoning when the percentage pays for real services at a reasonable value and does not rise with patients the company sends.
Med spas, IV hydration and lifestyle injectables
Idaho has no med spa license or registration in the Board of Medicine or Board of Nursing rules or guidance we read; IDAPA 24.33.01 regulates the physician who supervises instead. The Board's rule says the practice of medicine "includes the administration of parenteral admixtures and the performance of cosmetic treatments using prescriptive medical/cosmetic devices and products which penetrate or alter human tissue" (IDAPA 24.33.01.200.04.a, effective July 1, 2025). The supervising physician documents an evaluation, assessment and plan "prior to the initial treatment", is "on-site or immediately available" while medical personnel treat, verifies their training on a Board registration form kept "at each practice location", and may supervise no more than three medical personnel giving cosmetic treatments at the same time, or six if the Board grants a petition. Medical personnel may use only devices and products that are "exclusively non-incisive and non-ablative".
The Division of Occupational and Professional Licenses' guidance for professionals offering "lifestyle injectable medications" (adoption date March 13, 2026), in which the Boards of Barbers and Cosmetology Services, Dentistry, Medicine, Nursing and Pharmacy set out their concerns, lists peptides, fillers, IV hydration, IV ketamine, neurotoxins, PRP and "GLP-1s and other compounded weight loss products" (guidance). The guidance calls itself non-binding, but it notes that the term "medical director" "is not recognized in the practice acts or board rules" of those boards, and that "The supervising provider remains responsible for the care provided under their delegation, regardless of the amount of patient interaction." As the guidance describes it, Idaho Code 67-9407 has let any board under the Division of Occupational and Professional Licenses discipline a licensee who falls below the standard of care of similar professionals in similar settings since July 1, 2025. A clinic that sends medication home with a patient must register with the Board of Pharmacy as a Prescriber Drug Outlet (The Report, September 2025).
In our reading, none of these rules says who may own the business. An Idaho med spa owned by an esthetician or an investor still needs a licensed prescriber, and when a physician supervises its medical personnel, the evaluation, the on-site or immediate availability, the three-person limit and the responsibility stay with that physician personally.
How Idaho compares with North Carolina
North Carolina answers the ownership question in a Medical Board position statement: apart from listed exceptions, businesses practicing medicine there must be owned "in their entirety" by holders of active North Carolina licenses, and the Board may seek an injunction against lay owners (NCMB position statement 10.1.2, amended September 2025). Idaho's Board, writing in September 2025 about elective-care clinics, listed aesthetician and business owners among their business models and went on to what the physicians who prescribe for them must do; we found no Idaho Board statement like North Carolina's. Idaho's control point is the physician's own license: lending it (IDAPA 24.33.01.300.03.c), or handing supervision to a business entity (200.04.b.vii), is what the rules forbid.
In our reading, the 9% National Hearing Services fee that Idaho's Attorney General's office accepted in 1989 is the kind of arrangement North Carolina's fee statement describes. North Carolina's Board says that, "Except in instances permitted by law" (it cites G.S. 55B-14(c)), "a licensee cannot share revenue on a percentage basis with a non-licensee", and that doing so "is fee splitting and is grounds for disciplinary action" (NCMB position statement 10.1.1, amended September 2021). Idaho's office accepted the fee because it paid for "sales, marketing, advertising, training and consulting", not referrals. In our reading, the two rules differ in kind: Idaho's 54-1814(8), as quoted in 1989, reaches fees divided "in exchange for referral", while North Carolina's statement reaches a percentage revenue share with a non-licensee whether or not referrals are involved.
For the North Carolina side of the ownership and fee comparison above, see who can own a med spa in North Carolina; Idaho's neighbors in this series are Washington and Montana, and every state is at who can own a medical practice, by state.
Check a management fee for a Idaho practice
Compare a flat fee, cost plus a markup and a percentage of collections, and see which Idaho and federal rules bear on the one you are considering. The figures stay in your browser.
What the rules say about this structure
Idaho rules
1989 Attorney General guideline: a 9% service fee was not fee splitting
Idaho Code § 54-1814(8), as the Attorney General quoted it in 1989, makes it a ground for discipline to divide fees "with any person, institution or corporation in exchange for referral." Reviewing physicians' payments to a preferred provider organization of "nine percent (9%) of the Gross Revenue" from its members, the office found "the service fee is not paid in exchange for referral of patients" and "appears reasonably related to the services provided" (guideline, July 12, 1989). In our reading, a percentage management fee fits that reasoning when it pays for real services at a reasonable value. The current § 54-1814 could not be read on November 18, 2026, and House Bill 703 (2026) revised disciplinary language across practice acts.[4][3]
§ 54-1814(8): pay for marketing as a service, not per referral
The 1989 guideline accepted a percentage fee that paid the organization for its "sales, marketing, advertising, training and consulting endeavors", because "the service fee is designed to compensate NHS for administrative expenses" rather than for referrals. The ground for discipline it applied, § 54-1814(8) as quoted then, reaches fees divided "in exchange for referral." In our reading, an Idaho management company may be paid for marketing the practice, but a fee per patient referred, or one the company earns only when it sends patients, is the arrangement the statute names. The guideline is informal, dates from 1989, and read the statute as it stood then.[4]
Board rules: no lending the license, no handing supervision to the business
The Board of Medicine disciplines a licensee for "Allowing another person or organization to use his or her license or permit to practice his or her profession" and for "Employing, supervising, directing, aiding, or abetting" an unlicensed person who performs licensed services (IDAPA 24.33.01.300.03.c, 300.04.e). A physician who supervises medical personnel "accepts full responsibility" for their treatments, and those duties "may not be transferred to a business entity, professional corporation, or partnership" (200.04.b, b.vii). The Board's September 2025 newsletter repeats the license point while describing clinics owned by "aestheticians or business professionals." In our reading, an Idaho management agreement must leave the 200.04 evaluation, the on-site or immediate availability and the three-person limit with the physician.[1][2]
Professional corporation: professional services only (AG Op. 77-23)
The Attorney General read Idaho's Professional Service Corporation Act in 1977 to mean a professional corporation "may not actively engage in any other business which is unrelated to the rendering of professional services", though it may own property needed for its services and passively invest its funds (Op. 77-23, March 23, 1977). The Secretary of State's current forms cite Title 30, Chapter 21 instead, and that chapter could not be read on November 18, 2026. In our reading, if Chapter 21 kept the 1977 purpose limit, the management business belongs in its own company, not inside the physicians' professional corporation.[5][6]
Idaho Medicaid may deny payment for a prohibited physician referral; no state self-referral law found
Idaho's Medicaid fraud rule lets the Department of Health and Welfare deny payment for items or services "Provided as a result of a prohibited physician referral under 42 CFR Part 411, Subpart J" and recoup amounts already paid (IDAPA 16.05.07.200.01.d, 205). We found no Idaho self-referral or patient brokering statute in the sources we could read; the Idaho Code site did not accept connections on November 18, 2026, so the Code itself was not searched. In our reading, if the management company's owners refer Medicaid patients to the practice, Idaho Medicaid enforces the federal referral limits through payment.[7]
Idaho Board of Medicine rules and newsletters, Attorney General opinions and guidelines in the annual reports, the Secretary of State's professional entity forms and the Medicaid fraud rule that bear on a management fee between an Idaho practice and a management company, read on November 18, 2026; the Idaho Code site could not be read that day, and the federal rules show for every state.
Sources for the Idaho notes
- IDAPA 24.33.01, Rules of the Board of Medicine for the Practice of Medicine and Osteopathic Medicine in Idaho (current rules as published June 12, 2026; 200.04 and 300 mostly effective July 1, 2025) (as of November 18, 2026)
- Idaho State Board of Medicine, The Report, September 2025 (Popular Treatments and the Medical Provider) (as of November 18, 2026)
- Idaho State Board of Medicine, The Report, June 2026 (House Bill 703, universal discipline procedure, effective July 1, 2026) (as of November 18, 2026)
- Idaho Attorney General, legal guideline to Rep. Thomas L. Morrison, Division of Professional Fees (July 12, 1989), 1989 Annual Report pp. 158 to 160 (as of November 18, 2026)
- Idaho Attorney General, Opinion No. 77-23, powers of professional corporations under I.C. 30-1307 (Mar. 23, 1977), 1977 Annual Report pp. 151 to 154 (as of November 18, 2026)
- Idaho Secretary of State, Articles of Incorporation (Professional Service Corporation), Title 30, Chapters 21 and 29, rev. 01/2019 (as of November 18, 2026)
- IDAPA 16.05.07, The Investigation and Enforcement of Fraud, Abuse, and Misconduct (Department of Health and Welfare; sections 200 and 205 effective Mar. 17, 2022) (as of November 18, 2026)
Federal rules
The Anti-Kickback Statute reaches federal program business
The federal Anti-Kickback Statute makes it a felony to knowingly and willfully offer, pay, solicit or receive any remuneration to induce, or in return for, referrals or the arranging for or recommending of items or services for which payment may be made in whole or in part under a federal health care program. The criminal maximum is a $100,000 fine and 10 years in prison, and OIG may also impose a civil penalty of up to $127,973 per act, the 2025 level that HHS kept for 2026. A management fee is protected by the personal services and management contracts safe harbor only if it meets every condition, but OIG says failing one "does not render an arrangement automatically illegal"; the arrangement is then reviewed on "the totality of the facts and circumstances, including the intent of the parties."[1][2][3][4][5][7]
Signed writing, every service listed, one-year term
The safe harbor requires the agreement to be "set out in writing and signed by the parties", to cover and specify all of the services the MSO provides to the practice for the term, and to run for "not less than 1 year." OIG has said the writing can be one signed agreement or a signed collection of documents that together contain every required element. Its compliance guidance also asks whether the parties document the services they provide and whether arrangements "are actually conducted according to the terms of the written agreements."[5][6][7]
Fair market value and commercial reasonableness
The fee methodology must be "consistent with fair market value in arm's-length transactions", and the services contracted for may not exceed those "reasonably necessary to accomplish the commercially reasonable business purpose of the services." OIG has declined to define either term for the Anti-Kickback Statute and is barred by statute from opining on fair market value in an advisory opinion, so the figures in this estimator are not a fair market value finding. OIG's compliance guidance asks, "Is the determination of fair market value based upon a reasonable methodology that is uniformly applied and properly documented?", and in Advisory Opinion 25-03 the requestors certified each fee as consistent with fair market value "as established by a reputable, independent third-party valuator."[5][6][7][11]
A fixed fee is set in advance
A fixed fee for a written list of services is a compensation methodology set in advance, and because it does not change with the number of patients or the practice's collections, it does not move with referrals or business generated between the parties. In Advisory Opinion 25-03, OIG concluded that fees a practice would pay to a management services organization and the telehealth practice it manages would not generate prohibited remuneration, where the requestors certified that the fee methodology would be set in advance and consistent with fair market value, noting that paying the hourly fee "regardless of whether" the practice was reimbursed "decreases the likelihood" that the fee takes into account the volume or value of referrals or business generated between the parties. An advisory opinion protects only the parties that requested it, and a fixed fee still has to be consistent with fair market value for the services actually provided.[5][11]
Percentage fee and the volume-or-value condition
Since January 19, 2021, the safe harbor requires the compensation methodology, rather than the total amount, to be set in advance, so, in our reading, a percentage fixed in the signed agreement is not ruled out on that ground alone. The harder condition is that the methodology may not take into account "the volume or value of any referrals or business otherwise generated between the parties" that federal programs pay for, and a fee measured by collections rises with that business whenever the MSO or its owners help generate it. In 1998 OIG said percentage compensation for marketing services "may implicate" the statute and stated a "longstanding concern that percentage billing arrangements may increase the risk of upcoding and similar abusive billing practices." Missing the safe harbor is not itself a violation; the arrangement is then judged on its facts, including intent.[5][6][8][9][7]
Cost-plus: costs and markup fixed before payment
OIG said in its 2020 rule that an arrangement can fit the safe harbor "by using an hourly rate or other set, verifiable formula", but that whether an employee lease paid on "actual expenses incurred" meets the set-in-advance condition "would depend on the facts and circumstances." Parties must determine "whether the compensation methodology over the term of the agreement is set in advance before any payment under the arrangement is made", which in our reading means the cost categories, the markup and the way costs are verified belong in the signed agreement. OIG's example was that a bonus taking into account referrals between the parties, passed through as a cost, would leave the compensation unprotected, and the markup is part of the compensation that must be consistent with fair market value.[6][5]
Paying the MSO to bring in patients
The Anti-Kickback Statute reaches payment for "arranging for or recommending" federally payable items or services, not only for direct referrals, and OIG said in 1998 that percentage compensation for marketing services "may implicate" the statute. In 2022 OIG described a per-patient-encounter fee as a "per-click" fee structure, which "generally is inherently reflective of the volume or value of referrals or business otherwise generated between the parties." Measured against the safe harbor, a marketing fee fixed in advance for defined advertising work does not vary with the patients generated; a percentage or per-patient fee does.[1][8][10][5]
Fees between parties who refer to each other
When the MSO's owners or affiliates and the practice refer patients to each other, the management fee runs between parties who can generate federal program business for each other. OIG's compliance guidance asks, "Is the entity paying an inflated rate to a potential referral source?" and whether a party is "receiving free or below-market-rate items or services", so the fee can be questioned whether it sits above or below fair market value. The safe harbor also excludes a methodology that takes into account "the volume or value of any referrals or business otherwise generated between the parties"; a percentage of collections rises with the patients the owners send, while a fixed fee does not.[7][5]
Stark: physician owners and designated health services
Stark bars a physician who has a financial relationship with an entity, an ownership interest or a compensation arrangement, directly or through an immediate family member, from referring Medicare patients to it for designated health services such as clinical laboratory, radiology and imaging, physical therapy and outpatient prescription drugs, and bars the entity from billing for them, unless an exception applies. The entity is the one that performs or bills those services, usually the practice or an affiliate rather than a management-only MSO, and an ownership interest can run through an entity that owns the provider. Each element of an exception must be met; the personal service arrangements exception, for example, requires a signed writing specifying the services, a term of at least 1 year, and compensation "set in advance" that "does not exceed fair market value" and is not determined in any manner that takes into account "the volume or value of referrals or other business generated between the parties."[12][13][14]
General information for modeling management fee structures, not legal advice; whether a fee is consistent with fair market value is a question for a documented valuation of the services, not a calculator.
Sources for the federal notes
- 42 U.S.C. 1320a-7b(b), the Anti-Kickback Statute (uscode.house.gov, current through Pub. L. 119-124) (as of November 17, 2026)
- 42 U.S.C. 1320a-7a(a)(7), civil money penalty for kickbacks (uscode.house.gov, current through Pub. L. 119-124) (as of November 17, 2026)
- 45 CFR 102.3, inflation-adjusted civil money penalties (eCFR, up to date as of Nov. 13, 2026) (as of November 17, 2026)
- HHS, No Adjustment to HHS Civil Monetary Penalty Amounts for 2026, 91 FR 66566 (Oct. 21, 2026) (as of November 17, 2026)
- 42 CFR 1001.952(d), personal services and management contracts safe harbor (eCFR, up to date as of Nov. 13, 2026) (as of November 17, 2026)
- OIG final rule amending the safe harbors, 85 FR 77684 (Dec. 2, 2020; effective Jan. 19, 2021) (as of November 17, 2026)
- HHS-OIG, General Compliance Program Guidance (Nov. 6, 2023) (as of November 17, 2026)
- HHS-OIG Advisory Opinion No. 98-4 (Apr. 15, 1998): management company paid costs plus a percentage of practice revenue (as of November 17, 2026)
- HHS-OIG, Compliance Program Guidance for Third-Party Medical Billing Companies, 63 FR 70138 (Dec. 18, 1998; listed in OIG's CPG archive) (as of November 17, 2026)
- HHS-OIG Advisory Opinion No. 22-09 (Apr. 25, 2022): per-patient-encounter fees (as of November 17, 2026)
- HHS-OIG Advisory Opinion No. 25-03 (June 6, 2025): fees to telehealth management services organizations (as of November 17, 2026)
- 42 U.S.C. 1395nn, physician self-referral (Stark) law (uscode.house.gov, current through Pub. L. 119-124) (as of November 17, 2026)
- 42 CFR 411.351, Stark definitions, including entity (eCFR, up to date as of Nov. 13, 2026) (as of November 17, 2026)
- 42 CFR 411.357(d), Stark personal service arrangements exception (eCFR, up to date as of Nov. 13, 2026) (as of November 17, 2026)
Compare Idaho with other states
Each colored state has its own page, read at that state's own sources.
- Lay investors may not own the medical practice
- Some forms barred, no broader rule found
- Lay ownership possible in some form
- Covered: read the details
- Not covered yet
Common questions
Does Idaho have a corporate practice of medicine doctrine?
Not in any Idaho source we could read: no Board of Medicine rule or statement, no Attorney General opinion or guideline in the annual reports since 1975, and no statute as official sources quote it (the Code itself and the Supreme Court's opinions could not be read on November 18, 2026). In our reading, Idaho's limits fall on licensees: letting another person or organization use a license is a ground for discipline (IDAPA 24.33.01.300.03.c), and a supervising physician's duties may not be transferred to a business entity (IDAPA 24.33.01.200.04.b.vii).
Can a non-doctor own a medical practice in Idaho?
In our reading, not a professional corporation or PLLC: the Secretary of State's PLLC form describes members licensed for the entity's profession, and the 1977 act, as the Attorney General quoted it, limited shareholders to licensees. No Idaho source we read bars a business owned by people who are not licensees from offering medical treatments through licensed prescribers; the Board of Medicine's September 2025 newsletter describes clinics owned by aestheticians or business professionals and holds their physicians to its rules.
Can a nurse practitioner own a practice in Idaho?
Yes, in our reading, for care within the APRN license. IDAPA 24.34.01.200.04.a calls the APRN "a licensed independent practitioner", and nursing is on the 30-21-901(b) list of professions that may form a professional corporation or PLLC, as the Secretary of State's forms print it.
Can a physician assistant own a practice in Idaho?
No Idaho source we read answers that. A PA may practice only under a written collaborative practice agreement with at least one Idaho-licensed physician, unless employed by a facility with credentialing and privileging systems (Board of Medicine FAQ, citing Idaho Code 54-1807A).
Can a management company charge a percentage of revenue in Idaho?
In 1989 the Attorney General's office said a physician's service fee of 9% of gross revenue to a preferred provider organization was not fee splitting under Idaho Code 54-1814(8), because it paid for services, not referrals. That guideline read the 1989 statute; the current text could not be read on November 18, 2026.
Does an Idaho med spa need a medical director?
Not by that name. The March 2026 lifestyle injectables guidance says the term "medical director" is not recognized in the practice acts or board rules of the Boards of Barbers and Cosmetology Services, Dentistry, Medicine, Nursing or Pharmacy. A physician who supervises cosmetic treatments documents an evaluation before the first treatment, is on-site or immediately available, and supervises no more than three medical personnel at once, or six with the Board's approval (IDAPA 24.33.01.200.04).
Update log
- November 18, 2026. Published. Covers the absence of a stated corporate practice rule in the Idaho sources read, the Board of Medicine's license-use and supervision rules, professional corporations and PLLCs under Title 30, Chapter 21, nurse practitioners and physician assistants, the Attorney General's 1977 opinion on professional corporations and 1989 guideline on a percentage service fee, and the Board's rules for cosmetic treatments and lifestyle injectables. Read at the source November 18, 2026: IDAPA 24.33.01, 24.33.02 and 24.34.01; the Board of Medicine's newsletters (September 2025, June 2026), its collaborative practice FAQ and the March 13, 2026 lifestyle injectables guidance (dopl.idaho.gov); the Secretary of State's professional entity forms; the Attorney General's annual reports for 1977, 1989, 1992 and 1999 to 2025; and the NC Medical Board's position statements. The Idaho Legislature's statutes site did not accept connections and the Idaho Supreme Court's site returned HTTP 403, so statutes are described as the Attorney General, the Board and the Secretary of State quote or cite them.
Sources
- IDAPA 24.33.01, Rules of the Board of Medicine for the Practice of Medicine and Osteopathic Medicine in Idaho (current rules as published June 12, 2026; most of sections 200.04 and 300 effective July 1, 2025)
- IDAPA 24.33.02, Rules for Licensure of Physician Assistants (current rules as published June 12, 2026)
- IDAPA 24.34.01, Rules of the Idaho Board of Nursing (current rules as published June 12, 2026)
- Idaho State Board of Medicine, The Report, September 2025 (Popular Treatments and the Medical Provider)
- Idaho State Board of Medicine, The Report, June 2026 (sent June 15, 2026)
- Idaho Division of Occupational and Professional Licenses, Guidance for Healthcare Professionals Offering Lifestyle Injectable Medications (adopted Mar. 13, 2026)
- Idaho State Board of Medicine, Frequently Asked Questions, Collaborative Practice (physician assistants)
- Idaho Secretary of State, Articles of Incorporation (Professional Service Corporation), rev. 01/2019
- Idaho Secretary of State, Certificate of Organization, Professional Limited Liability Company, rev. 01/2019
- Idaho Attorney General, Opinion No. 77-23, powers of professional corporations under I.C. 30-1307 (Mar. 23, 1977), 1977 Annual Report pp. 151 to 154
- Idaho Attorney General, legal guideline to Rep. Thomas L. Morrison, Division of Professional Fees (July 12, 1989), 1989 Annual Report pp. 158 to 160
- NC Medical Board, Corporate Practice of Medicine, position statement 10.1.2 (adopted Mar. 2016, amended Sept. 2025)
- NC Medical Board, Referral Fees and Fee Splitting, position statement 10.1.1 (adopted Nov. 1993, amended Sept. 2021)
Related
Building a practice, MSO or med spa that reaches into Idaho?
DPS Law structures North Carolina medical practices, med spas and the management companies that serve them.